Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

By Newsy Staff

By Newsy Staff
April 5, 2018

April 5, 2018

Newsy partners with Intelligence Squared U.S. to restore critical thinking. In this debate, experts weigh the pros and cons of charter schools.

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

In partnership with Intelligence Squared U.S., Newsy brings you a snapshot of "Up for Debate." In this episode, experts debate if charter schools are overrated. Catch a new episode of the full debate Sunday at 9 a.m. ET.

TRENDING IN U.S. NEWS

HeidiBougghanmi2014 / CC BY SA 3.0

Envelope With Deadly Poison Ricin Intercepted En Route To White House

Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 1977

Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States via AP

Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s Cultural Impact

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and President Bill Clinton in 1993

Doug Mills / AP

What Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg Meant To Women

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Craig Fritz / AP

Ginsburg Remembered As A Champion Of Women's Rights

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Associated Press

World Leaders Pay Tribute To Ruth Bader Ginsburg And Her Legacy

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Alex Brandon / AP

Politicians, Celebrities React To Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Death

Satellite image of several systems in the Atlantic Ocean

3 Tropical Storms Formed In About 6 Hours

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg speaks at Stanford University in Stanford, Calif.

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP

Reflecting On Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Legacy

Heavy smoke from wildfires envelops the Willamette Bridge and downtown Portland, Oregon.

Don Ryan via AP

Which COVID-19 Mask Works For Wildfire Smoke?

May 2016 photo of Venus, seen from Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency's Akatsuki probe.

J. Greaves / Cardiff University via AP

NASA Considers Venus Mission After Scientists Find Potential Life Sign

Photo of Ronald Greene's car

Family photo / AP

Newly Surfaced Photos Raise Questions About Death Of Black Man In LA

President Donald Trump arrives to speak at a campaign rally at Central Wisconsin Airport.

Evan Vucci / AP

Former Model Amy Dorris Accuses President Trump Of Sexual Assault

Response team helps rescue residents in Pensacola, Florida

Tony Giberson / Pensacola News Journal / AP

Recovery Efforts Continue Following Hurricane Sally

Fires in Oroville, California

Noah Berger / AP

Firefighters Start Getting Better Handle On Blazes In The West

A sample mail-in ballot for Hawaii's primary election

Audrey McAvoy / AP

Judge Orders Postal Service To Stop Recent Policy Changes

In Controversial Speech AG Barr Criticizes His Own DOJ Prosecutors

A student wears a protective masks at the Immaculate Conception School while observing COVID-19 protocols

New York City Delays In-Person Classes Again

Police officers stand outside St. Francis Medical Center on Monday.

Ashley Landis / AP

Los Angeles Sheriff's Deputy Released From The Hospital

Firefighter Cody Carter battles the North Complex Fire in Plumas National Forest, Calif

Noah Berger / AP

West Coast Wildfire Smoke Now Seen In Europe

National Guard Maj. Adam DeMarco testifies during a House Natural Resources Committee hearing

Leah Millis / AP

Federal Officials Considered Using 'Heat Ray' On Protesters

A sample mail-in ballot for Hawaii's primary election

Audrey McAvoy / AP

States Fight Back Against Cuts At U.S. Postal Service

Boeing 737 Max planes parked

737 Max Pilot: House Report 'Ringing Condemnation' Of Boeing Culture

Former Donald Trump campaign official Michael Caputo leaves after being interviewed by Senate Intelligence Committee staff

J. Scott Applewhite / AP

Department of Health and Human Services Appointee Takes 2 Month Leave

LA: Pall bearers carry a casket with the body of Lydia Nunez, who died from COVID-19.

Associated Press

Pandemic: Financial Hardship Felt Most By Communities of Color

In this image taken from police body camera video a Rochester police officer puts a hood over the head of Daniel Prude

Roth and Roth LLP / AP

NY Officials Tried to Withhold Information About Death of a Black Man

A customer wears a mask and looks at their cell phone as they carry their order past a now hiring sign.

LM Otero / AP

Fifth Consecutive Year U.S. Poverty Rate Falls

A nurse at Irwin County Detention Center in Ocilla, Georgia, speaks at a Tuesday news conference in Atlanta.

Jeff Amy / AP

Dems Call For Investigation Into Reports Of Forced Medical Procedures

Jason Ravnsborg speaks in Sioux Falls, S.D.

AP / Dirk Lammers

SD Officials Promise 'Thorough' Probe Into Attorney General Crash

firefighter battles Creek Fire

Noah Berger / AP

Scientists Debate Climate Change, Human Activity Amid Fires, Storms

President Trump at the White House on Tuesday.

Alex Brandon / AP File

President Trump Threatens Iran Over Alleged Plot On U.S. Ambassador

Tamika Palmer, mother of Breonna Taylor, addresses the media in Louisville, Ky., on Thursday, Aug. 13, 2020.

Dylan Lovan / AP

Louisville Settles Historic $12M Lawsuit With Breonna Taylor's Family

A pharmacist gives the first shot in a clinical trial of a potential COVID-19 vaccine

Who Gets COVID-19 Vaccine First?

Federal Authorities Launch Investigation Into Ronald Greene's Death

This image released by Netflix shows the cast of the coming-of-age film "Cuties."

Netflix "Cuties" Sparks Concerns It Violates Child Pornography Laws

Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf

Matt Rourke / AP

Pennsylvania Lockdown Ruled Unconstitutional

Greg Kelly, left, arrives for the first trial hearing at the Tokyo District Court in Tokyo Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2020.

Third Party / Kiyoshi Ota / AP

Former Nissan Executive Pleads Not Guilty To Criminal Conspiracy

Acting Department of Homeland Security Secretary Chad Wolf

Susan Walsh / AP

Judge Blocks Homeland Security Asylum Rules, Wolf Appointment Invalid

Waters from the Gulf of Mexico pour onto a local road.

Gerald Herbrt / AP

Gulf Coast Braces For Hurricane Sally's Impact

A woman carries an American flag during a protest outside the U.S. Consulate in Hong Kong.

Kin Cheung / AP

U.S. Issues Travel Warning For China And Hong Kong

Rochester, New York, Mayor Lovely Warren

Adrian Kraus / AP

Rochester, NY, Mayor Fires Police Chief Over Response To Prude's Death

This April 25, 2017, file photo, shows Exxon service station signs in Nashville, Tenn. Exxon Mobil Corp.

Mark Humphrey / AP

Connecticut Files Suit Against Exxon Mobil On Climate Change

Record breaking wildfires burn in Oregon, turning the sky a hazy orange.

Evacuating During Oregon Wildfires

Fire damage is seen in Mill City, Ore.

Gillian Flaccus / AP

At Least 35 People Killed In Wildfires Across The U.S.

Lancaster City Police body camera video

Lancaster City Bureau of Police

Tense Protest After Man Killed By Police In Pennsylvania

Department of Homeland Security seal

Carolyn Kaster / AP

Whistleblower Complaints On Russian Interference Follow Pattern

Michael Bloomberg speaks during the Democratic National Convention

Democratic National Convention / AP

Bloomberg Spending $100 Million To Boost Biden Campaign In Florida

A man shot at two sheriff's deputies while they were sitting in their patrol cars.

Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department

Man Shoots LA County Sheriff's Deputies Sitting in Squad Car

U.S. Marine Lance Cpl. Joseph Scott Pemberton, right, sits as Bureau of Immigration agents check his documents

Philippines' Bureau of Immigration Public Information Office / AP

U.S. Marine Who Killed Transgender Woman Deported From Philippines

Firefighters work to control a blaze near Big Sur, California.

Nic Coury / AP

33 Dead, Dozens Unaccounted for As Fires Burn Western States

Nurses at drive-thru COVID-19 testing in Bismarck, N.D.

Tom Stromme / The Bismarck Tribune /AP

North Dakota, South Dakota See Highest COVID-19 Growth Rate In U.S.

Mike Pence with Donald Trump in the foreground

Andrew Harnik / AP

Pence Abandons Appearance At Fundraiser Hosted by QAnon Backers

Man advocates for Amendment 4 with shirt that says "Past Mistakes Should Not Define a person's future"

Wilfredo Lee / AP

Appeals Court Rules That Many Florida Felons Can't Register To Vote

OxyContin pills

Toby Talbot / AP

FDA: Updated OxyContin Not Successful In Decreasing Overdoses, Deaths

Police in riot gear attempt to clear protesters in Richmond, VA.

Steve Helber / AP

Virginia Pushing For Police Decertification Over Excessive Force

Planes parked on the tarmac at Kansas City International Airport

Lessons From 9/11 Recovery Give Airlines Guideposts For COVID-19

William Valentin

9/11 First Responder Struggles With COVID-19 Recovery

Dr. Anthony Fauci testifies before Congressional committee July 31.

Erin Scott / Pool via AP

Dr. Fauci: U.S. Must 'Hunker Down' As New COVID-19 Dangers Loom

Rubble remains from an area destroyed by the Almeda Fire, Friday, Sept. 11, 2020, in Talent, Ore.

John Locher / AP

Oregon Wildfires Force More Than 10 Percent Of Population To Evacuate

A Target store.

Sue Ogrocki / AP

Target Announces Initiative To Increase Number Of Black Employees

Alex Brandon / AP and Mary Altaffer / AP

Trump And Biden Visit 9/11 Memorials In New York And Pennsylvania

An envelope containing a 2020 census letter mailed to a U.S. resident in Detroit.

Court Blocks Order To Keep Undocumented Immigrants Off Census

Gregory Bull / AP

How Are Small Colleges Handling COVID-19?

A researcher holds vape pens in a laboratory in Portland, Ore.

Craig Mitchelldyer / AP

E-Cigarette Use Down Among Teens

John Mormando beat a 9/11-related cancer as well as COVID-19

John Mormando

9/11 Workers, Survivors Face New Challenge With COVID-19

A tribute to Nicolas Chavez, 27, who was shot and killed April 21 by several police officers during a confrontation

Houston Chronicle / Mark Mulligan / AP

Houston Officers Fired After Shooting Death Of Man

September 11th National Memorial Trail Alliance

9/11 Trail Linking Three Memorial Sites Continues To Expand

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin announced sanctions over alleged election meddling on Thursday.

Graeme Jennings / Pool via AP

U.S. Sanctions Ukrainian Official, 3 Russians For Election Meddling

Naomi Osaka, of Japan, fires a ball into the stands after defeating Shelby Rogers

AP Photo/Frank Franklin II

Tennis Stars Take A Stand Against Racial Injustice

Volunteer participates in COVID-19 vaccine trial

Associated Press

Diversity Needed in COVID-19 Vaccine Trials

Woodward, facing widespread criticism for now revealing President Trump's early concerns about the severity of the virus

Cliff Owen / AP

President Trump Defends Downplaying The Threat Of COVID-19

The Department of Justice building.

Justice Department Announces New Charges In PPP Fraud Cases

A Kansas City Chiefs fan walks outside the stadium before Super Bowl 54 in 2020.

Seth Wenig / AP

Native American-Style Dress, Paint Won't Be Part Of NFL Opener

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks during a news conference at the State Department in Washington, Wednesday, Sept. 2

Nicholas Kamm / AP

U.S. Has Revoked More Than 1,000 Visas Of Chinese Nationals Since June

A camera with facial recognition capabilities

Carolyn Thompson / AP

Portland, Oregon, Bans Use Of Facial Recognition Technology

An Oscar statue

Danny Moloshok / Invision / AP

The Academy Announces New Inclusion Critera For Oscars Eligibility

Capt. Tammie Jo Shults

Tammie Jo Shults/HarperCollins Publishing

Life-Saving Pilot To Newsy: 'Everyone Felt The Value Of Human Life'

Social justice-focused Instagram posts aligned in a grid.

To Learn About Race, Gen Z And Millennials Turn To Social Media

Protestors march in support of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and Temporary Protected Status (TPS) programs

AP Photo/Lynne Sladky

Immigrants With Protected Status Sue To Restore Path To Green Cards

The Bear Fire burns in Oroville, Calif.

Noah Berger / AP

Strong Winds Intensifying California Wildfires

Bikers ride down Main Street during the 80th annual Sturgis Motorcycle Rally.

Amy Harris / AP

Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Reportedly Led To 260,000 COVID-19 Cases

AstraZeneca offices in Cambridge, England

Associated Press

Late-Stage COVID-19 Vaccine Trial On Hold

President Trump

Evan Vucci / AP

President Trump To Announce A Further Troop Reduction In Middle East

Voters wait in line to cast their ballots in the state's primary election at a polling place, Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Ron Harris / AP

Georgia Investigating Possible Double-Voting

E. Jean Carroll talks to reporters outside a courthouse in New York

Seth Wenig / AP

Justice Department Wants To Defend President In Defamation Lawsuit

Rochester Police Chief La'Ron Singletary at Sept. 3 community meeting.

Adrian Kraus / AP

Rochester Chief, Top Deputy Retire Amid Uproar Over Daniel Prude Death

Picture from Civil Rights Movement in 1960s

Two Activists Draw Parallels Between Civil Rights Movement And Today

Joseph Griffin on Facebook Live while being detained

Black Man Offered Job By Sheriff's Office That Wrongly Detained Him

Aug. 24, 2020, file photo, Postmaster General Louis DeJoy

House Launches 'Straw-Donor' Investigation Of Postmaster General

Firefighters battle the Creek Fire in the Shaver Lake community of Fresno County, Calif.

Noah Berger / AP

Firefighters Battle Multiple Wildfires In California

Marijuana plants are pictured at Baker Medical in Oklahoma City.

Sue Ogrocki / AP

House To Make Historic Vote On Marijuana Legalization

U.S. Hotel Industry Takes A Hit Over Labor Day Holiday

Unsolicited seed packages

Washington State Dept. of Agriculture

Amazon Bans Foreign Seed Sales In The U.S.

President Donald Trump speaks during a news conference at the White House.

President Trump Bans 'Un-American' Anti-Racism Training

Joe Prude, center, brother of Daniel Prude, takes a moment before speaking as he observes the crowd gathered during a rally.

Adrian Kraus / AP

Rochester Mayor Promises Police Reform

Beach goers set up an umbrella

Jae C. Hong / AP

Tourism Industry Shows Slight Improvements Over Labor Day Weekend

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange take part in a protest outside the Central Criminal Court

Matt Dunham / AP

Julian Assange's Extradition Hearing Resumes After Delay