Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

By Newsy Staff

By Newsy Staff
April 5, 2018

April 5, 2018

Newsy partners with Intelligence Squared U.S. to restore critical thinking. In this debate, experts weigh the pros and cons of charter schools.

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

In partnership with Intelligence Squared U.S., Newsy brings you a snapshot of "Up for Debate." In this episode, experts debate if charter schools are overrated. Catch a new episode of the full debate Sunday at 9 a.m. ET.

TRENDING IN U.S. NEWS

Lori Loughlin and daughter

Chris Pizzello / Invision / AP

College Admissions Scandal Prosecutors Push Back On Misconduct Claims

Quarantine and care facility at Cook County Jail

Chicago's County Jail Is Facing The U.S.' Worst COVID-19 Outbreak

Caleb and Ashlee White

Life Has Changed: U.S. Couple Stranded In New Zealand Amid Pandemic

Grocery store clerk cleans checkout area

Associated Press

Essential Workers Can Return To Work After Potential COVID-19 Exposure

Groceries bagged in single use plastic bags

Gillian Flaccus / AP

States Loosen Plastic Bag Bans Over Coronavirus Concerns

"For Sale By Owner" and "Closed Due to Virus" signs

AP / Paul Sancya

U.S. Jobless Report: Unemployment Increases To 5.1%

A JBS USA beef plant where workers went on strike due to lack of coronavirus protections

Some Meat Processing Plants Have Shuttered As Workers Catch COVID-19

A nurse works in protective clothing in a hospital room

Marcel Kusch / AP

Coronavirus Diagnosis Could Lead To Surprise Medical Bills

People stand outside in Massachusetts.

New COVID-19 Models Predict Lower Total U.S. Death Toll

Nurse Brittney Groover, center, runs through procedure with other health professionals in the mobile field clinic

Rogelio V. Solis / AP

CDC Issues New Guidance For Essential Workers Who Are Asymptomatic

Man stands outside the New York State Department of Labor

John Minchillo / AP

6.6 Million Americans Filed For Unemployment Last Week

Former Acting Navy Secretary Thomas Modly

Alex Brandon / AP

Resigned Navy Official's Guam Trip Cost U.S. $243,000

Marc Cooper, Owner of Tissue Plus

Tim Ouillette

Life Has Changed: Toilet Paper Company Faces Sudden Surge In Demand

Women in Chicago's South Side

Associated Press

Is COVID-19 Disproportionately Killing Black Men?

Anthony Fauci with President Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

U.S. Officials Consider Relaxing Lockdown Requirements

inmates walk around a recreation yard at the Deuel Vocational Institution in Tracy, Calif.

COVID-19 Is Forcing Cities Into The Future Of Criminal Justice Reform

The Washington Monument

Andrew Harnik / AP

D.C. Struggles To Keep Residents Inside, Braces For Virus Surge

Person in mask with workbook

Matt Rourke / AP

How Are Educators Prioritizing Students' Mental Health?

Dr. Anthony Fauci

Alex Brandon / AP

Fauci Says U.S. Should Be In 'Good Shape' For School In The Fall

Abortion protestors outside an Indiana Planned Parenthood

AP / Michael Conroy

Appeals Court Upholds Texas Abortion Ban Amid Coronavirus

A screenshot from a Zoom video conference

AP / The Rev. Laura E. Everett

Lawmakers Call For Investigation Into Zoom

AP / Alex Brandon

Acting Navy Secretary Resigns After Calling Captain 'Stupid'

Life Has Changed: Child Therapist Fears Effects Of COVID-19

A photograph taken by Stephanie Keith depicts a pharmacist wearing personal protective equipment in Queens, New York.

Stephanie Keith

What's It Like To Cover the Pandemic?

American Airlines plane

Gene J. Puskar / AP

American Airlines Cuts Flights To NYC Area From 271 To 13 A Day

U.S. Department of Defense

Acting Navy Secretary Sorry For Calling Ex-Commander 'Stupid, Naive'

Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit, Michigan

AP / Paul Sancya

Detroit Hospitals Report Spike In Cases Among Workers

The USNS Comfort arrives in New York City

Crew Member On USNS Comfort Tests Positive For COVID-19

Female recruits in their first 24 hours of military training learn basic formation commands on June 14, 2006.

Army Pauses Sending Recruits To Basic Training Over Coronavirus

Boeing 787-10 Dreamliner

Mic Smith / AP

Boeing Shuts Down South Carolina Operations Amid Stay-At-Home Order

Chef Noel Argote-Herrera

Life Has Changed: Idaho Chef Sells Food Curbside To Stay In Business

Defense Secretary Mark Esper

Alex Brandon / AP

Defense Department Issues New Guidance On Face Coverings

COVID-19 Drive Thru Testing

The Associated Press

The Race to Develop COVID-19 Tests

A white rose lies on a headstone

Livestreaming Funerals: Is This The New Norm?

The CDC recently issued new guidelines saying people who smoke and vape are at higher risk for severe COVID-19 complications.

CDC Says Smoking, Vaping Increase Hospitalization Risk For COVID-19

Former USS Theodore Roosevelt Captain Tests Positive For COVID-19

Bail bonds neon sign

New York Partially Rolls Back Controversial Bail Reform

A pedestrians crosses a mostly empty Sixth Avenue during the coronavirus outbreak

Frank Franklin II / AP

Trump Says Coronavirus Outbreak May Be Nearing Peak In Some Areas

A car turns in at a location for drive-thru COVID-19 testing at Prisma Richland Hospital on Friday, April 3, 2020

AP / Meg Kinnard

Home COVID-19 Tests Still Aren't Approved, But Results Getting Faster

An airline passenger walks by the vacant TSA checkin at the Detroit Metropolitan Airport, Monday, March 23, 2020

AP / Carlos Osorio

Airlines Must Reimburse Customers For COVID-19 Flight Cancellations

cages of ventilators in New York City

Mark Lennihan / AP

NY Governor To Order Redistribution Of Ventilators

Woman wearing face mask and gloves

Damian Dovarganes / AP

CDC Officially Recommends Americans Wear Nonmedical Masks

Army soldiers transport supplies as part of setting up a field hospital in Seattle

U.S. Department of Defense

Army Sets Up Medical Tents In Seattle To Alleviate Local Hospitals

Dr. Anthony Fauci

Alex Brandon / AP

Fauci Says All States Should Be Under Stay-At-Home Orders

Navy hospital ship

Seth Wenig / AP

New York City Is Running Out Of Supplies To Help Coronavirus Patients

Pacific Gas & Electric vehicles are parked at the PG&E Oakland Service Center in Oakland, Calif.

Ben Margot / AP

California Fire Victims Seek Updated Settlement With PG&E

Jason Rezaian on newsy

Jason Rezaian Talks About Living in Isolation

President Donald Trump and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin

AP / Alex Brandon

Memo: Some Americans May Not Receive Coronavirus Aid Until August

The National Guard stands in formation at the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center in New York City

John Minchillo / AP

White House Says Military Will Operate COVID-19 Facilities

Billie Eilish and her mom Maggie Baird

Maggie Baird Instagram

Billie Eilish's Mom Has A Plan To Get Food To First Responders

EMT workers in New York City

John Minchillo / AP

NYC First Responders Work To Address Unprecedented Number Of Calls

A closed sign hangs in the window of a shop in Portsmouth, N.H., due to caronavirus

Charles Krupa / AP

Small Businesses Can Start Applying For Coronavirus Relief Loans

Capt. Brett Crozier

Navy Captain Relieved Of Command After Sharing COVID-19 Concerns

Life Has Changed: New York City Bike Shops Are Essential Businesses

Actress Lori Loughlin, and husband, clothing designer Mossimo Giannulli

AP / Steven Senne

Parents In College Admissions Scandal Ask Judge To Dismiss Charges

A man wearing a face mask

Damian Dovarganes / AP

Experts Say Coronavirus Can Spread Through Talking, Breathing

Wi-Fi hotspot school bus

Meg Kinnard / Associated Press

How Are Schools Dealing With The Digital Divide?

The Zaandam cruise ship

AP / Arnulfo Franco

Florida Reaches Agreement With Cruise Ships To Disembark

A cell phone is used to live stream mass by Archbishop Paul D. Etienne at St. James Cathedral

Elaine Thompson / AP

Americans Urged To Avoid Church Services Of More Than 10 People

A plane flies overhead

Frank Augstein / AP

Trump Considering Halting U.S. Flights Between Coronavirus Hot Spots

NYPD officer wearing a mask

John Minchillo / AP

More Than 1,000 NYPD Officers Have COVID-19

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis arrives at a mobile testing site for coronavirus in The Villages, Fla., on March 23.

John Raoux / AP

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis Issues Stay-At-Home Order

Tori Fulgate with dogs

Kevin McKinney

Life Has Changed: 'Fostering Pets Is The Cool Thing To Do Right Now'

Andrew Shafer

'They're Going To Do Their Job:' Police Amid Coronavirus Pandemic

Lauri Mazurkiewicz

Lauri Mazurkiewicz

Nurses Say They Were Fired For Voicing Concerns Amid Pandemic

Florida Department of Economic Opportunity sign

Florida's Broken Unemployment System Is Causing Problems Statewide

Cruise ships docked at PortMiami in Florida

Wilfredo Lee / AP

Coast Guard Issues New Evacuation Rules For Cruise Ships

A U.S. Army soldier walks inside a mobile surgical unit.

Army Asking Individual Ready Reserve Soldiers To Fight Coronavirus

A Census Bureau employee walks up to a home

U.S. Census Bureau

April 1 Marks U.S. 'Census Day'

Medical personnel talk outside the emergency room at NewYork-Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital, Wednesday, March 18, 2020

AP / Mary Altaffer

Major Medical Staffing Company Cuts Salaries, Benefits For ER Workers

USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier

Bullit Marquez / AP

U.S. Aircraft Carrier In Guam Asks For COVID-19 Help

File photo shows Portland Marriott Downtown Waterfront in Portland, Oregon

Rick Bowmer / AP

More Than 5 Million Customers Affected In Latest Marriott Hack

A mother with her newborn baby.

Tech Support: How Some Doulas Plan to Deliver Virtual Care

A man wearing a mask bicycles along a section of the Grand Concourse that has been temporarily closed to vehicular traffic

Mark Lennihan / AP

Health Expert Says Social Distancing Measures Are Working

Coach Who Disarmed Student Receives U.S.' Highest Civilian Honor

Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker

Charles Rex Arbogast / AP

Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker Extends Stay-At-Home Order

Life Has Changed: New York Doctor Changes Practice To Telemedicine

University of Chicago's Ci3 lab created a deck of cards with questions to help providers and patients navigate conversations

Newsy / Andrew Shafer

Transgender, Non-Binary People Want Visibility In Reproductive Health

Illinois state prison Stateville Correctional Center

Rw2 at English Wikipedia

Coronavirus Cases In Prisons Continue To Spread After Deadly Weekend

Planned Parenthood

Rick Bowmer / AP

Appeals Court: Texas Can Ban Abortions Amid Pandemic

Volunteer workers stand near a 68 bed emergency field hospital in New York

AP Mary Altaffer

New York Gov. Says 1 Million More Health Care Workers Are Needed

A gavel in a court room.

Do Closed Courts Violate A Defendant's Sixth Amendment Rights?

Medical personnel outside a coronavirus testing tent in Florida

Chris O'Meara / AP

COVID-19 Fatalities Surpass 3,000 In U.S.

Jazz trumpeter Efrem Towns

How Life Has Changed For One Jazz Musician In New Orleans

Researcher works inside a lab at Colorado State University to fight COVID-19.

Colorado State University

Colorado Lab Working On Vaccine, Disinfectant Against COVID-19

Gov. Ralph Northam

AP / Steve Helber

Virginia Issues Official Stay-At-Home Order

Andrea Schry, right, fills out the buyer part of legal forms to buy a handgun.

Keith Srakocic / AP

Poll: 1 in 20 Households Bought A Gun In Response To COVID-19

The USNS Comfort

U.S. Navy Ship Docks In NYC To Care For Non-Coronavirus Patients

A highway checkpoint set up in Florida

Florida Department of Transportation

Florida Sets Up Checkpoints To Screen Motorists From COVID-19 Hotspots

Dr. Anthony Fauci

AP / Alex Brandon

Fauci Says 100,000 To 200,000 In U.S. May Die From Coronavirus

Todd Favakeh tested positive for coronavirus after returning home from a ski trip in Austria

Chicago Man Fighting Coronavirus Shares His Experience

New York City amid coronavirus outbreak

Photographer: Mary Altaffer / AP

New York City To Fine Social Distancing Violators

The Mall at Turtle Creek in Jonesboro, AR.

Jonesboro Police Department

Tornado In Jonesboro, Arkansas, Leaves 22 Injured

A sign outside a fly fishing shop in tiny Maupin, Oregon, advises customers of new policies

AP / Gillian Flaccus

AP Analysis: Most Counties Without COVID-19 Cases Are Rural

Empty New York streets

AP / Bebeto Matthews

Trump Issues Travel Advisory For NY Area; Stops Short Of Quarantine

Members of the Rhode Island National Guard look for passengers getting off from a train from New York as it arrives Saturday

David Goldman / AP

Rhode Island Troops Stop Vehicles With New York Plates