Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

Up For Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?

By Newsy Staff

By Newsy Staff
April 5, 2018

April 5, 2018

Newsy partners with Intelligence Squared U.S. to restore critical thinking. In this debate, experts weigh the pros and cons of charter schools.

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

In partnership with Intelligence Squared U.S., Newsy brings you a snapshot of "Up for Debate." In this episode, experts debate if charter schools are overrated. Catch a new episode of the full debate Sunday at 9 a.m. ET.

TRENDING IN U.S. NEWS

Christopher Columbus statue vandalized with red paint

Michelle R. Smith / AP

Lawmakers Propose Removing Columbus Day's Federal Holiday Status

Crews removing statue of Stonewall Jackson

Steve Helber / AP

Richmond Mayor Orders Confederate Statues Be Removed From City Land

American Airlines CEO Doug Parker

American Airlines, Newsy

Exclusive: American Airlines CEO Says Distancing Not Possible

A stack of paperwork detailing positive COVID-19 test results sits in a box.

What Went Wrong In The U.S.' COVID-19 Fight?

A copy of the Emancipation Memorial in Boston

Steven Senne / AP

Boston To Remove Statue of Abraham Lincoln With Kneeling Slave

Seattle police stand on a road in the Capitol Hill Organized Protest zone early Wednesday, July 1, 2020.

Aron Ranen / AP

Seattle Mayor Orders CHOP Zone Evacuated

demonstrators carry a giant placard during a rally and march over the death of 23-year-old Elijah McClain.

David Zalubowski / AP

Justice Dept. Has Been Looking Into Elijah McClain's Death For Months

American soldiers waiting for a helicopter to land in Afghanistan

Rahmat Gul / AP / File

U.S. Officials: Financial Transfers Corroborate Russian Bounties

A member of the Florida National Guard talks to a driver as he monitors vehicles entering a testing site for COVID-19.

Lynne Sladky / AP

U.S. Records 48,000 New Cases Of COVID-19 In One Day

Protesters hold portraits of Breonna Taylor

Timothy D. Easley / AP

Louisville To Investigate Handling Of Breonna Taylor's Case

Statue of Alexander Hamilton Stephens in the U.S. Capitol Stephens was vice president of the Confederacy.

Patrick Terpstra / Newsy

8 States Keep Confederate Statues On Display In U.S. Capitol

Man examines protective barriers at a casino card table

Wayne Parry / AP

New Jersey Bans Indoor Smoking, Drinking And Eating At Casinos

Garrett Rolfe and Rayshard Brooks

Atlanta Police Department / AP

Officer Charged With Killing Rayshard Brooks Granted $500,000 Bond

Demonstrators demand justice for Elijah McClain

David Zalubowski / AP

Officers Investigated After Taking Photos At Elijah McClain Memorial

Sign announcing beach closure

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP

Los Angeles County To Close Beaches For 4th Of July Weekend

A person packing boxes

What's The Risk Of Moving Into A New Place?

School custodian

Darron Cummings / AP

Health Officials Say Following Guidelines Is Key For Reopening Schools

National Guardsmen at Washington Monument

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP

White Supremacist In National Guard Was Deployed To Floyd Protests

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds

Charlie Neibergall / AP

Iowa Governor Signs Waiting Period Abortion Law

A potluck dinner.

What's The Risk Of A Potluck?

Honoree Carl Reiner addresses the audience at "The Paley Honors

Chris Pizzello / Invision / AP

Hollywood Actor, Director Carl Reiner Dies At 98

A member of the Secret Service Police stands guard outside the fence of the White House

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

AP: White House Knew About Alleged Russian Bounties In 2019

Patrick Semansky / AP

YouTube Bans Several High-Profile White Supremacist Channels

Courtroom sketch of Derek Chauvin

Judge In George Floyd Case Threatens To Move Trial Location

Seth Perlman / AP

Pepsi, Ford And More Join List Of Brands Boycotting Social Media Ads

A statue of actor John Wayne at John Wayne Orange County Airport

Reed Saxon / AP

Orange County Lawmakers Push To Drop John Wayne's Name From Airport

AP Photo/Jeff Chiu

Reshaped By Pandemic, Cities Claim Streets For More Than Just Cars

Dmitry Astakhov / Sputnik / AP

Questions Mount After Reports Russia Paid Taliban To Kill U.S. Troops

A battered car sits in the Capitol Hill Organized Protest zone following a shooting in Seattle.

Aron Ranen / AP

1 Dead, 1 Hospitalized In Seattle CHOP Zone Shooting

Anti-abortion rights protester

Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Abortion Law

Mark and Patricia McCloskey holding guns

St. Louis Couple Points Guns At Protesters Passing Their House

Police fire pepper balls at protesters

David Zalubowski / Associated Press

How Police Brutality Is Tied To America's Gun Culture

The White House are visible behind a statue of President Andrew Jackson in Lafayette Park.

Andrew Harnik / AP

Four Charged With Attempting To Remove Andrew Jackson Statue in DC

A Boeing 737 Max being built for Norwegian Air International taxis for a test flight

Ted S. Warren / AP

FAA Approves Test Flights Of Boeing's Updated 737 Max Jet

Mailer supporting psychedelic drug decriminalization

Zach Cusson / Newsy

The Push To Decriminalize Psychedelic Drugs

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before leaving The White House

AP / Alex Brandon

President Trump Retweets Video Of Supporter Shouting 'White Power'

Paratroopers conduct a rapid extraction (EXFIL) following a fly-to-advise mission in Southeastern Afghanistan.

President Trump Casts Doubt on Russia Bounty Report

The current Mississippi state flag

Rogelio V. Solis / AP

Mississippi Lawmakers Pass Legislation To Change The State Flag

File photo of Walmart distribution center

Gunman Kills 1, Injures 4 At California Walmart Distribution Center

A protester in front of the St. Paul, MN governor's mansion on Saturday, June 6, 2020.

Julio Cortez / AP

Minneapolis City Council Greenlights Amendment To Dismantle Police

Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton

Carolyn Kaster / AP

House Approves Washington, D.C., Statehood Bill

The White House

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

President Trump Signs Order To Protect Nation's Monuments

The Emancipation Memorial in Washington, D.C.

J. Scott Applewhite / AP

Calls Grow To Remove Abraham Lincoln Statues In D.C. And Boston

U.S. Supreme Court building

Qualified Immunity: Unjust Or Necessary?

No entry sign on Texas business

David J. Phillip / AP

Texas Governor Shuts Down Bars, Scales Back Restaurant Dining

Uber app on a smartphone

What's The Risk Of Catching COVID-19 From Using A Ride-Share?

Education Secretary Betsy DeVos speaks about the coronavirus.

Alex Brandon / AP

Secretary DeVos Issues Rule Directing Aid Money To Private Schools

Dr. Rick Bright testifies before a House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health hearing.

Shawn Thew / AP

Ousted Vaccine Official Alleges Ongoing Retaliation Against Him

Brehanna Daniels

One Of NASCAR's Newest Faces Welcomes Push For Inclusivity

A city worker measures the statue of Christopher Columbus at Marconi Plaza

Matt Slocum / AP

Philadelphia Intends To Remove Statue Of Christopher Columbus

A woman holds up a sign saying "police the police" as she confronts a police line while demonstrators protest in Washington.

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

House Passes Police Reform Legislation, Faces Senate Pushback

Deputies from Harris County Sheriff's Office fire taser at African American woman seated in wheelchair

Security video obtained by Randy Kallinen, Attorney

Investigation: Police Ignore FBI Request For 'Use Of Force' Data

Concept art of "New Adventures With Princess Tiana" ride

Disney Reimagining Splash Mountain Around 'The Princess And The Frog'

Associated Press

Maria Ressa Warns Erosion Of Democracy Is Happening In The U.S.

A man wearing a face mask

David J. Phillip / AP

CDC Says 20 Million Americans Are Likely Infected With The Coronavirus

Mary W. Jackson

Robert Nye / NASA

NASA Renaming D.C. Headquarters After Mary W. Jackson

COVID-19 test site

Matt York / AP

In 2 Weeks, 10 States Have Seen New COVID-19 Cases Double

A coronavirus antibody testing site in Utah

Texas Pauses Reopening, ICU Beds Fill As Virus Cases Spike Across U.S.

Protesters hold Elijah McClain T-shirt

David Zalubowski / AP

Colorado Governor Orders Reexamination Of Elijah McClain's Death

A statue of Andrew Jackson near the White House

Andrew Harnik / AP

Report: Trump Administration Asks U.S. Marshals To Protect Monuments

Missouri's only abortion clinic

Jeff Roberson / AP

Missouri's Last Abortion Clinic Issued License After Yearlong Battle

Person on an e-scooter

What's The Risk Of Using An E-Scooter?

Steven Senne / AP

Protests Haven't Fueled Coronavirus Surges As Officials Feared

The Grand Princess cruise ship is shown docked at the Port of Oakland in Oakland, Calif.

Jeff Chiu / AP

Cruise Industry Extends No-Sail Order

Protesters block traffic at an intersection an intersection near Capitol Square in Madison, Wisconsin.

Emily Hamer / Wisconsin State Journal / AP

Wisconsin Governor Activates National Guard Following Unrest

California Gov. Gavin Newsom wears a protective mask on his face while speaking to reporters

Jeff Chiu / AP

California Continues To Break Daily COVID-19 Records

A healthcare worker at a COVID-19 testing site in Texas

David J. Phillip / AP

Federal Government To Stop Funding 13 Coronavirus Testing Sites

D.C. police officers with shields

Maya Alleruzzo / AP

Senate Democrats Block Republican Policing Bill

Worker at coronavirus testing site

States Scramble To Respond As U.S. Coronavirus Cases Spike Again

Gregory and Travis McMichael

Glynn County Detention Center / AP

3 Suspects Indicted On Murder Charges In Ahmaud Arbery's Death

Custodian cleans classroom desks

Tony Dejak / AP

COVID-19 Could Cost Schools Millions In Wages And Supplies

A statue of Andrew Jackson near the White House

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

Unarmed National Guardsmen Deployed To Protect D.C. Monuments

Black Lives Matter protesters and Minneapolis police

AP / Jim Mone

WSJ: Justice Department Considers Probe Into Minneapolis Police Force

Children playing with bubbles

What's The Risk Of Letting My Kids Play Outside?

Lawyer Daniel Brown holds a poster calling on Georgia lawmakers to pass a state hate crimes law.

Jeff Amy / AP

Georgia Hate Crime Bill Goes To Gov. Kemp's Desk

Someone paying with cash.

What's The Risk Of Using Cash?

Officer Brett Hankison

Louisville Police Department / AP

Louisville Police Fires Detective Involved In Breonna Taylor's Death

Matt Slocum / AP

Bill Cosby Granted Appeal In 2018 Sexual Assault Conviction

NASCAR driver Bubba Wallace

John Bazemore / AP

FBI Determines NASCAR Noose Incident Did Not Target Bubba Wallace

Memorial near the site where Robert Fuller was found hanged

Mark J. Terrill / AP

Series Of Hanging Deaths Spark Speculation About Potential Lynchings

Traveler in nearly empty airport

As Air Travel Rebounds, Airlines Still Have No National Safety Mandate

AP / Mike Groll

A Look At The DOD Program Giving Police Free Military Equipment

Caller dials 911

States Working To Curb Racially Biased 911 Calls

Black Lives Matter protesters in Utah

Rick Bowmer / AP

AP Poll Shows Most Americans Support Certain Police Reform Policies

First responders at door

City of Dallas

Less Police Involvement On Mental Health Calls Shows Fewer Arrests

Painting depicting woman at Black Lives Matter protest

Instagram / arswithlove

For These Black Artists, Public Art Can Be A Form Of Protest

People mourn Rayshard Brooks

Curtis Compton / Atlanta Journal-Constitution / AP

Family And Friends Remember Rayshard Brooks At Historic Atlanta Church

The seal of the State of Rhode Island decorates a podium.

David Goldman / AP

Rhode Island Weighs Changing Its Name Over Ties To Slavery

A protester picks up signs during a demonstration

Jae C. Hong / AP

Employees From Sheriff's, DA's Offices Accused Of Vandalizing BLM Sign

A statue of Andrew Jackson near the White House

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

Police Thwart Attempt To Pull Down Andrew Jackson Statue In D.C.

Statue of Theodore Roosevelt

Kathy Willens / AP

American Museum Of Natural History To Remove Theodore Roosevelt Statue

Patagonia store door

Robert F. Bukaty / AP

Patagonia Joins Ad Boycott Against Facebook And Instagram

Child playing Fortnite

Martha Irvine / AP

Fortnite Reportedly Removes All Police Vehicles From Game

A couple and a realtor

What's The Risk Of House Hunting?

Protesters outside of Minnesota State Capitol building

Jim Mone / AP

Minnesota Lawmakers End Special Session With No Reform Bill Passed

A police vehicle is parked outside the Uptown Theatre Sunday, June 21, 2020, following a shooting

Doug Glass / AP

1 Dead And 11 Injured In Uptown Minneapolis Shooting