SCOTUS Could Decide If US Protections Extend To Foreign Citizens
In 2010, a 15-year-old Mexican national was shot by a Border Patrol agent on Mexican soil.
The Supreme Court has agreed to take on a case that could decide whether U.S. constitutional protections can extend to foreign citizens on foreign soil.
Here's the case: according to the complaint, in 2010, 15-year-old Mexican national Sergio Adrián Hernández Güereca and his friends were playing a game at the U.S.-Mexico border between El Paso, Texas, and Ciudad Juarez, Mexico. The game involved running across the border onto U.S. soil, touching a fence and running back to the Mexican side of the border.
A U.S. Border Patrol agent showed up and detained one of the minors involved in the game. The lawsuit says Hernández ran back across the border to the Mexican side and stood on a pillar there. The agent then shot across the U.S.-Mexico border, killing him. The complaint says Hernández was "unarmed and unthreatening at the time."
The agent says he fired the gun because rocks were being thrown at him. Hernández's family filed suit, arguing the agent violated Hernández's Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights.
The case made it all the way to the high court, which heard oral arguments in 2017. The Supreme Court sent it back to a lower court for further proceedings.
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the Hernández family's lawsuit in March. It said extending certain actions to let the lawsuit go forward would "interfere with the political branches' oversight of national security and foreign affairs" and "create a remedy with uncertain limits."
Now, the Supreme Court is getting another crack at the case to decide whether U.S. constitutional rights can extend to foreign persons on foreign soil, allowing the family to sue for damages in U.S. courts.
Gay Rights And Religion Clash At The Supreme Court
A Colorado web designer is at the center of a controversial case for refusing to design websites for gay couples because of her Christian beliefs.By Andrew Harnik / AP
Supreme Court Hearing Cases On Same-Sex Couples, State Lawmaker Rights
Two significant cases will be heard at the Supreme Court this week that could have major implications nationally.By David Zalubowski / AP
Roberts Delays Handover Of Trump Tax Returns To House Panel
Roberts' order gives the Supreme Court time to weigh the legal issues in Trump's emergency appeal to the high court, filed Monday.By José Luis Villegas / AP
10 Common Habits That Can Jeopardize Your Dog's Health
Pet parents, don't slip into bad habits! Avoiding these behaviors now can help your pup have better health outcomes in the long run.By Victor Calzada / El Paso Times via AP
Drop In WIC-Approved Stores Sends Families Scrambling For Formula
A Newsy investigation found WIC, a government program that helps low-income parents pay for healthy food, is becoming harder to use.By Zach Cusson / Newsy
New York Times Journalists, Other Workers On 24-Hour Strike
Members of the NewsGuild of New York say they are fed up with bargaining that has dragged on since their last contract expired in March 2021.By Mark Lennihan / AP