Up For Debate: As We Evolve, Do We Still Need Religion?

Up For Debate: As We Evolve, Do We Still Need Religion?

By Newsy Staff

By Newsy Staff
July 5, 2018

July 5, 2018

Newsy partners with Intelligence Squared U.S. to restore critical thinking. In this debate: As we evolve, do we still need religion?

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

In partnership with Intelligence Squared U.S., Newsy brings you a snapshot of "Up for Debate." In this episode, experts debate what role religion plays in society as we continue to evolve. Catch a new episode of the full debate Sunday at 9 a.m. ET.

TRENDING IN U.S. NEWS

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP

President Trump Commutes Roger Stone's Prison Sentence

Protesters outside U.S. Capitol

New Federal Legislation Seeks To Defund Police And Close Prisons

American soldiers wait on the tarmac in Logar province, Afghanistan, in 2017.

Intelligence Briefers: Pres. Trump's Stance On Russia Bounty Unusual

Police gather in Portland

Doug Brown/AP

Portland Police Report $23M In Damage Over 6 Weeks Of Protests

Jason Janahanian, 39, is recovering after being in the ICU for COVID-19 in April 2020.

Younger COVID-19 Patients May Face Recovery Complications

Roman Catholic Church

Jeffrey T. Barnes / AP

U.S. Catholic Church Received At Least $1B In Federal COVID-19 Aid

President Donald Trump holds a chart as he talks with reporters after receiving a briefing on Hurricane Dorian

Evan Vucci / AP

Commerce Department Called Out Over Hurricane Dorian Forecast

TSA agent Patrisa Johnson assists travelers

Tony Gutierrez / AP

TSA Adds More COVID-19 Protections At Airports

Protesters clash with police near the Salt Lake County district attorney's office

Rick Bowmer / AP

State Of Emergency Declared In Utah Amid Protests

Defense Secretary Mark Esper testifies during a House Armed Services Committee hearing

Michael Reynolds / Pool / AP

Esper Says He Was Briefed On Alleged Russian Payments In February

John Minchillo / AP

Michael Cohen Back In Prison After Refusing Furlough Terms

Girls walk in Walt Disney World park

Walt Disney World Resort

Disney World Orlando Resort To Reopen Amid COVID-19 Case Spike

A glass of wine is poured

Elite Wine Instructor Told Black Student To Call Her 'Master'

American Airlines planes

Flying While Infected? No Federal Law Will Stop You

President Donald Trump

Evan Vucci / AP

White House Calls SCOTUS Orders A Win, Despite Immunity Decision

Supreme Court building

Andrew Harnik / AP

Supreme Court Finds Much Of Oklahoma Is Native American Land

Newsy's Amber Strong with Dr. Deborah Birx

Is Reopening Schools Safe? Dr. Deborah Birx Tells Newsy It Depends.

School custodian wearing face shield

Charlie Neibergall / AP

Schools Open In Florida Next Month. Are Educators Ready?

NYC employees painting "Black Lives Matter" mural

Office of NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio

New York City Paints 'Black Lives Matter' Mural Outside Trump Tower

Des Moines Public Schools custodian Cynthia Adams cleans a desk in a classroom at Brubaker Elementary School

Charlie Neibergall / AP

CDC Will Not Revise School Reopening Guidelines Despite Pressure

Jessica Knutson and her daughter Abigail, 3, place flowers at a memorial to George Floyd in Minneapolis

John Minchillo / AP

New Transcript Shows Floyd Told Police Repeatedly He Couldn't Breathe

Charles Krupa / AP

New York City Students To Return To Classroom Part Time

U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper, left, speaks during a briefing with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Army Gen. Ma

Susan Walsh / AP

Esper And Milley To Testify Thursday Before House Committee

A health care worker administering a COVID-19 test

Lynne Sladky / AP

U.S. Surpasses 3 Million Confirmed COVID-19 Cases

Fort Bragg sign

Chris Seward / AP

House Defense Bill Has $1M To Rebrand Bases Named For Confederates

President Donald Trump

As President Trump Pushes To Reopen Schools, Safety Guidance To Change

National Committee of Asian American Republicans at a Trump Rally in 2016

National Committee of Asian American Republicans

How 'Kung Flu' Rhetoric Impacts The Asian American GOP Vote

Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman

Andrew Harnik / AP

Key Impeachment Witness Alexander Vindman Retires From Army

Mark Zuckerberg

AP Photo / Eric Risberg, FILE

Audit Finds Facebook Made 'Devastating' Moderation Errors

People walking through the gates of Harvard Yard at Harvard University

Charles Krupa / AP

Harvard, MIT Suing ICE To Support International Students

Richmond Confederate Soldiers & Sailors Monument

Steve Helber / AP

Virginia's Capital Removes Another Confederate Statue

President Donald Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

President Threatens To Withhold Funding From Schools That Don't Reopen

Demonstrators kneel in a moment of silence over the death of George Floyd.

Ashley Landis / AP

Activists Unveil Criminal Justice Reform Proposal

Members of Little Sisters of the Poor

Supreme Court Upholds Religious Exemption Rule On Contraceptives

Still from video where Vauhxx Booker was reportedly assaulted

FBI Investigating Indiana Man's Reported Assault

A physician assistant prepares to collect a nasal swab sample from a patient for COVID-19.

Jae C. Hong / AP

FDA Warns Of False Positive COVID-19 Tests

Bronze statue of Andrew Jackson in front of Jackson, Miss., City Hall.

Rogelio V. Solis / AP

Mississippi City To Take Down Statue Of Andrew Jackson

Nurses at a drive-up coronavirus testing station set up by the University of Washington Medical Center

Ted S. Warren / AP

Health Care Workers Worried About Dwindling Medical Supplies

Dr. Anthony Fauci

Kevin Dietsch / AP

Fauci Warns Of 'False Complacency' As COVID-19 Death Rate Declines

President Donald Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

Trump Administration Notifies Congress It Will Withdraw From WHO

Deutsche Bank flag

Mark Lennihan / AP

Deutsche Bank Fined $150M For Epstein Account Handlings

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg

AP / Marcio Jose Sanchez

Facebook CEO Meets With Civil Rights Groups Behind Advertising Boycott

President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

White House Putting Pressure On States To Reopen Schools This Fall

International student Christian Jackson with friends at Drake University

Christian Jackson

International Students Will Have To Leave U.S. If Schools Move Online

Armed police watch protesters in Seattle

AP Photo/Elaine Thompson

Former Police Officers Explain The 'Blue Wall Of Silence'

People hug at protest

What History Teaches Us About Attacks On Peaceful Protesters

Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp walks away after speaking during a news conference at the state Capitol in Atlanta

Brynn Anderson / AP

Georgia Governor Declares State Of Emergency After Weekend Violence

Charles Krupa / AP

Florida Public Schools Ordered To Reopen For Fall

Empty base where Frederick Douglass statue once stood

Atyia Collins / News 8 WROC

Frederick Douglass Statue Vandalized On Anniversary Of Famous Speech

WNBA player Natasha Cloud

John Locher / AP

WNBA Dedicates 2020 Season To Social Justice Issues

As Police Divestment Gains Support, Summer Violence Raises Tensions

Kim Chandler / AP

Schools Push For Removing Names Of Confederate Leaders On Buildings

Dakota Access Pipeline construction

Tom Stromme / The Bismarck Tribune / AP

Judge Orders Temporary Shutdown Of Dakota Access Pipeline

Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez

Wilfredo Lee / AP

Miami-Dade County Mayor Reimposes COVID-19 Closures

A mural honoring Army soldier Vanessa Guillén.

Houston Chronicle / AP

Remains Of Missing Soldier Vanessa Guillen Positively Identified

A police officer in Chicago

Charles Rex Arbogast / AP

More Than A Dozen People Killed In Chicago Over July 4th Weekend

Police tape strung around Lavish Lounge's parking lot

Richard Shiro / AP

'Gang-Related' Shooting At South Carolina Club Concert Kills 2

Christopher Columbus statue in Baltimore

Nickel Lietzau / CC BY 2.0

Demonstrators Topple Christopher Columbus Statue In Baltimore

Authorities report to scene where two protesters were hit by a car

James Anderson / AP

Protester Hit By Car On Closed Freeway Dies Of Injuries

An F/A-18E Super Hornet flies over the flight deck of the Navy’s only forward-deployed aircraft carrier USS Ronald Reagan

U.S. Aircraft Carriers Conduct Drills In South China Sea

President Donald Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

President Trump Attends Mount Rushmore Fireworks Celebration

Wilson police officers Joshua Taylor and Brandon Dingman

Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation / AP

2 Oklahoma Police Officers Charged With Murder In Stun Gun Death

Demonstrators demand justice for Elijah McClain

David Zalubowski / AP

Officers Fired After Taking Photos At Elijah McClain Memorial

Alex Brandon / AP

Washington Redskins May Drop Team Name Under Pressure From Sponsors

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP

Mississippi Moves A Step Further Away From Prohibition

Chicago skyline

Kiichiro Sato / AP

Chicago Orders Incoming Travelers From Select States To Quarantine

Travelers walk through Terminal 3 at O'Hare International Airport in Chicago.

Nam Y. Huh / AP

Trump Administration Asks Air Travelers To Wear Face Masks

Sky Cubacub wears a window mask

How Window Masks Can Help The Deaf, Hard Of Hearing Amid The Pandemic

Maya Moore and Jonathan Irons

Maya Moore / Instagram

Missouri Man's Conviction Overturned After 22 Years Behind Bars

Customers and server in cafe

Marcio Jose Sanche / AP

New York City, California Halt Indoor Dining As COVID-19 Cases Rise

U.S. Army Considers Training Soldiers To Avoid Police Confrontations

The White House

Andrew Harnik / AP

DHS To Send Rapid Deployment Teams To Protect Federal Monuments

Corrections Officer at man entry to California's San Quentin State Prison.

Eric Risberg / AP

More Than 1,100 Inmates Infected With COVID-19 At San Quentin Prison

A supporter for the transgender community holds a trans flag.

Robin Rayne / AP

Trump Admin. To Roll Back Transgender Protections In Homeless Shelters

A demonstrator is taken into custody after the city's curfew went into effect in Los Angeles.

Jae C. Hong / AP

Los Angeles City Council Votes To Cut Police Funding

Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of late British publisher Robert Maxwell, reads a statement

Dominique Mollard / AP

FBI Arrests Jeffrey Epstein Confidant Ghislaine Maxwell

A man walks by a hiring sign

June Jobs Report Exceeds Economists' Expectations

community volunteer checks for appointments and directs cars lining up for coronavirus tests

Richard Vogel / AP

U.S. Records More Than 50,000 New Daily COVID-19 Cases

Christopher Columbus statue vandalized with red paint

Michelle R. Smith / AP

Lawmakers Propose Removing Columbus Day's Federal Holiday Status

Crews removing statue of Stonewall Jackson

Steve Helber / AP

Richmond Mayor Orders Confederate Statues Be Removed From City Land

American Airlines CEO Doug Parker

American Airlines, Newsy

Exclusive: American Airlines CEO Says Distancing Not Possible

A stack of paperwork detailing positive COVID-19 test results sits in a box.

What Went Wrong In The U.S.' COVID-19 Fight?

A copy of the Emancipation Memorial in Boston

Steven Senne / AP

Boston To Remove Statue of Abraham Lincoln With Kneeling Slave

Seattle police stand on a road in the Capitol Hill Organized Protest zone early Wednesday, July 1, 2020.

Aron Ranen / AP

Seattle Mayor Orders CHOP Zone Evacuated

demonstrators carry a giant placard during a rally and march over the death of 23-year-old Elijah McClain.

David Zalubowski / AP

Justice Dept. Has Been Looking Into Elijah McClain's Death For Months

American soldiers waiting for a helicopter to land in Afghanistan

Rahmat Gul / AP / File

U.S. Officials: Financial Transfers Corroborate Russian Bounties

A member of the Florida National Guard talks to a driver as he monitors vehicles entering a testing site for COVID-19.

Lynne Sladky / AP

U.S. Records 48,000 New Cases Of COVID-19 In One Day

Protesters hold portraits of Breonna Taylor

Timothy D. Easley / AP

Louisville To Investigate Handling Of Breonna Taylor's Case

Statue of Alexander Hamilton Stephens in the U.S. Capitol Stephens was vice president of the Confederacy.

Patrick Terpstra / Newsy

8 States Keep Confederate Statues On Display In U.S. Capitol

Man examines protective barriers at a casino card table

Wayne Parry / AP

New Jersey Bans Indoor Smoking, Drinking And Eating At Casinos

Garrett Rolfe and Rayshard Brooks

Atlanta Police Department / AP

Officer Charged With Killing Rayshard Brooks Granted $500,000 Bond

Demonstrators demand justice for Elijah McClain

David Zalubowski / AP

Officers Investigated After Taking Photos At Elijah McClain Memorial

Sign announcing beach closure

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP

Los Angeles County To Close Beaches For 4th Of July Weekend

A person packing boxes

What's The Risk Of Moving Into A New Place?

School custodian

Darron Cummings / AP

Health Officials Say Following Guidelines Is Key For Reopening Schools

National Guardsmen at Washington Monument

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP

White Supremacist In National Guard Was Deployed To Floyd Protests