Supreme Court Nominee's Judicial History Under Scrutiny

Supreme Court Nominee's Judicial History Under Scrutiny

By Alexandra Miller

By Alexandra Miller
July 10, 2018

July 10, 2018

The president has made his pick to replace Anthony Kennedy on the Supreme Court. Now the drama begins.

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

President Donald Trump nominated Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court on Monday evening. By doing so, he chose a mainstream Republican pick. But while he should sail through confirmation, his judicial history is being called into question.

TRENDING IN Politics NEWS

Counselor to the President Kellyanne Conway speaks with reporters outside the White House.

Kellyanne Conway Ignores House Committee Subpoena, Fails To Appear

U.S. Capitol Building

What Exactly Does Being Held In Contempt Of Congress Mean?

Twitter Says Trump's Racist Tweets Don't Violate Its Rules

President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un

North Korea Threatens To Resume Nuclear Testing

A Customs and Border Protection patch

CBP Investigating Employee Participation In Secret Facebook Group

Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Ayanna Pressley, Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib

CNN Newsource

Democratic Congresswomen Respond To Trump's Racist Tweets

Rep. Steny Hoyer speaks during an event to introduce the Raise The Wage Act.

Washington Roundup: Democrats Unite Over Minimum Wage

Democratic presidential candidate, former Vice President Joe Biden gives a speech on July 11, 2019 in New York City.

Biden Wants To 'Protect and Build on Obamacare'

What's Really Behind China's Economic Slowdown?

President Donald Trump

Trump Doesn't Back Down Amid Criticism Over His Racist Tweet

Members of a caravan of Central Americans.

Trump Administration Rule Sets 'New Bar' For Asylum Seekers

Two women test out Huawei phones

U.S. To Reportedly Allow Sales To Huawei In 2 To 4 Weeks

Central American migrants head toward the U.S.

Guatemalan Court Blocks Signing Of 'Safe Third-Country' Agreement

A man is detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents

ICE Raids Reportedly Start Quietly In NYC And Other Cities

Lawmakers tour a detention center

Rep. Jackie Speier

Democrats Visit Texas Detention Center, Say Conditions Are 'Inhumane'

Department of Justice building

Justice Department Gets Appeals Court Win In Sanctuary Cities Case

Construction of border wall prototype near California-Mexico border.

Trump Administration Asks Supreme Court To Overturn Border Wall Ruling

Robert Mueller's House Judiciary Panel Testimony Delayed A Week

President Trump speaks to a crowd gathered at the Lincoln Memorial, July 4, 2019.

The White House

Letter Details Park Service Spending On Trump July 4th Event

The 9/11 Memorial

House Passes Bill To Extend 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund

President Donald Trump

House Votes To Block Trump From Launching Military Strike Against Iran

Tents at U.S. Border Patrol station in Clint, Texas

House Panel Examines Alleged Mistreatment Of Minors At CBP Facilities

Democratic presidential candidate Beto O'Rourke greets supporters in Iowa.

Luke Piotrowski

Beto O’Rourke Talks With Newsy About His Plan For Voting Rights

Central American asylum seekers wait as U.S. Border Patrol agents take them into custody.

House Report: 18 Children Under 2 Separated From Families At Border

Labor Secretary Alexander Acosta

Labor Secretary Acosta Resigns Amid Controversy Over Epstein Plea Deal

A California firefighter battles the 2018 Camp Fire

California Lawmakers Approve Multibillion-Dollar Wildfire Fund

U.S. soldiers saluting

House Approves Amendment To Overturn Transgender Military Ban

President Donald Trump

Trump Issues Executive Order To Determine Citizenship Status Of U.S.

A Chicago lawyer and immigrant advocate tells people during a press conference that undocumented immigrants have rights.

Madeline Carl / Newsy

How Immigrant Advocates Are Preparing For Possible ICE Raids

People protest census citizenship question

How The Census Is Tackling Potential Miscounts — And Why It Matters

Prescription drug bottles

Trump Administration Drops Plan That Would've Eliminated Drug Rebates

Attorney General William Barr

House To Vote On Holding Barr, Ross In Contempt Over Census

A woman video conferences with a doctor.

Telemedicine Can Save Lives In Rural Areas, But It's Still Hard To Get

President Doland Trump greets rally attendees at Williamsport Regional Airport, May 20, 2019 in Montoursville, Pennsylvania

What Do We Actually Know About Political Censorship On Social Media?

House Judiciary Committee

House Panel Approves Subpoenas For 12 Current, Former Trump Officials

A look at one of the bedrooms at HHS's Carrizo Springs facility

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Trump Administration Opens New Facility For Unaccompanied Migrant Kids

A U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent.

ICE Reportedly Sets A Date For Immigration Raids

Pete Buttigieg talks with voters.

Buttigieg Comment On Racial Disparity Lacks Data To Back It Up

Justice Department Tries To Prevent Mueller Associates From Testifying

Surveillance camera

Lawmakers Consider Facial Recognition Technology Oversight

Facial-recognition technology

ICE's Use Of Facial Recognition Tech Could Threaten Women Of Color

Military flyover at the National Mall

DC Wants Reimbursement For President Trump's 4th Of July Celebration

Outgoing U.K. Ambassador to the U.S. Kim Darroch

Ambassador's Resignation Roils U.K. Leadership Race

Sen. Cory Booker

Trump Campaign Criticizes Booker For Past Donations From Big Pharma

Ticker-tape parade in New York City for the U.S. Womens Soccer team

One Senator Wants To End Funding For The World Cup Over Pay Equality

Federal Reserve building

How The Federal Reserve's Size Lets It Influence Interest Rates

U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit

Acroterion / CC BY SA 3.0

Appeals Court Blocks Emoluments Lawsuit Against President Trump

A doctor speaks with a patient

California To Pay For Some Undocumented Immigrants' Health Benefits

Dry, cracked ground

Lawmakers Unveil Measure To Make Climate Change A National Emergency

The White House.

Trump Administration Threatens To Veto Massive Defense Bill

Kim Darroch, the U.K. ambassador to the U.S.

Kim Darroch Resigns As British Ambassador To The U.S.

Federal Appeals Court Hears Oral Arguments In Obamacare Case

Sample 2010 census form

Judge Rules DOJ Can't Change Legal Team In 2020 Census Case

Former Combat Pilot Is Challenging Mitch McConnell In Ky. Senate Race

Iran's Bushehr nuclear power plant

How Uranium Enrichment Fuels Iran’s Nuclear Program

Alexander Acosta.

Lawmakers Call For Acosta's Resignation Over Epstein Plea Deal

Cars driving on expressway

U.S. Governors Come Out Against Freeze In Fuel Efficiency Standards

President Donald Trump

Appeals Court: President Trump Can't Block His Critics On Twitter

Philanthropist Tom Steyer Announces Presidential Run

Former Presidential Candidate Ross Perot Dead At 89

A man reaches for a medicine bottle.

Judge Blocks Trump Administration Rule Requiring Drug Prices In TV Ads

Flags and the U.S. Capitol

Washington Roundup: What Is Sequestration?

The Trump International Hotel in Washington

Congressional Democrats Subpoena Trump Organization

Money in a wallet

CBO: Raising Federal Minimum Wage To $15 Could Mean 1.3M Job Cuts

Sample 2010 census form

White House To Reveal Legal Approach For Census Citizenship Question

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo

Mike Pompeo Unveils New Commission On Unalienable Rights

A surveillance camera

Researchers: FBI, ICE Use Facial Recognition Software On DMV Photos

Rep. Eric Swalwell

Democratic Candidate Is Leaving 2020 Presidential Race

U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to members of the media prior to a departure from the White House June 18, 2019 in DC.

Why Trump Isn't Pushing This Tool That Can Flag Undocumented Workers

President Donald Trump in New York

New York Passes Law Giving Congress Access To Trump's State Tax Info

Michelle Bachelet.

UN Human Rights Chief 'Appalled' By U.S. Migrant Detention Facilities

A video surveillance camera hangs from the side of a building.

FBI, ICE Reportedly Using Driver's Licenses For Facial Recognition

Acting Homeland Security Secretary Kevin McAleenan

DHS Says Number Of Migrant Kids In CBP Custody Has Decreased

CBP officers check migrants' IDs

Trump Is Wrong To Blame Obama For Family Separation Policy

A woman fills out a test questionaire

U.S. Census Bureau

Justice Department Changing Its Legal Team On The 2020 Census Case

A U.S. Customs and Border Protection officer's patch

Internal Memo Reveals CBP Knew About Facebook Group Last Year

U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation Zalmay Khalilzad

U.S., Taliban Hold 'Most Productive' Peace Talks To Date

Democratic presidential candidate Beto O'Rourke speaks to voters in Iowa.

Newsy / Luke Piotrowski

Not Every Vote For President Counts The Same. Should That Change?

Border wall construction

U.S. Customs and Border Protection

What's The Status Of Wall Construction Along The U.S.-Mexico Border?

Liz Scheier donated her eggs three times

Luke Piotrowski/Newsy Staff

Egg Donor Advocates Call For More Regulation As Industry Surges

The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals

Appeals Court Puts Hold On Title X Abortion Restrictions

U.S. Rep. Justin Amash holds a Town Hall Meeting on May 28, 2019 in Grand Rapids, Michigan

Rep. Justin Amash Leaves Republican Party

EU Parliament President David-Maria Sassoli

European Parliament

European Parliament Elects David Sassoli As Its New President

President Donald Trump

Appeals Court Upholds Freeze On Military Funds For Border Wall

woman with natural hair

California Bans Discrimination Based On Natural Hair

Woman taking census

U.S. Census Bureau

Trump Administration Still Pushing For Census Citizenship Question

As seen through fencing, migrants enter a Border Patrol vehicle while being detained.

Newsy Finds CBP And ICE Are Failing To Meet Their Own Standards

Undocumented immigrants leave a U.S. federal court in shackles.

Immigration Judges Are In Very Short Supply. Here's Why

Russian President Vladimir Putin

Putin Formally Suspends Russia's Participation In INF Treaty

Members of a caravan of Central Americans walk from Mexico to the U.S. side of the border.

Judge Blocks Trump Administration Order Denying Asylum-Seekers Bail

Commerce Department Tells Staff To Still Treat Huawei As Blacklisted

Overcrowding of families observed by OIG

Office of Inspector General

Report Outlines 'Serious' Overcrowding, 'Urgent' Conditions At Border

President Donald Trump

President Trump, RNC Raise $105 Million In Second Quarter Donations

Migrants sit in a crowded Texas facility in June 2019.

Office of Inspector General

Rep. Dean: Our Common Humanity Seems Absolutely Missing

Sample census 2010 form

What Is Census Data Really Used For, And What Can Be Shared?

What's The Story Behind The 15-Year US-EU Aircraft Subsidy Dispute?