Supreme Court Nominee's Judicial History Under Scrutiny

Supreme Court Nominee's Judicial History Under Scrutiny

By Alexandra Miller

By Alexandra Miller
July 10, 2018

July 10, 2018

The president has made his pick to replace Anthony Kennedy on the Supreme Court. Now the drama begins.

SHOW TRANSCRIPT

President Donald Trump nominated Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court on Monday evening. By doing so, he chose a mainstream Republican pick. But while he should sail through confirmation, his judicial history is being called into question.

TRENDING IN Politics NEWS

Former special counsel Robert Mueller during a House Intelligence Committee hearing

Alex Brandon / AP

Mueller Says Stone Still A 'Convicted Felon' Despite Commutation

President Donald Trump wears a face mask as he walks down a hallway during a visit to Walter Reed Military Hospital

Patrick Semansky / AP

President Trump Wears Mask In Public For The First Time

Protesters outside U.S. Capitol

New Federal Legislation Seeks To Defund Police And Close Prisons

Republican National Convention 2016

Gene J. Puskar / AP

GOP Convention Planning Underway As Cases Spike In Florida

American soldiers wait on the tarmac in Logar province, Afghanistan, in 2017.

Intelligence Briefers: Pres. Trump's Stance On Russia Bounty Unusual

President Trump

AP/Sue Ogrocki

Trump Campaign Postpones Rally As Tropical Storm Fay Nears East Coast

Aisha Kazman Kammawie takes the Oath of Allegiance during a drive-thru naturalization ceremony in Des Moines, Iowa.

AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall

Naturalization Delays Could Hold Up Scores Of Prospective 2020 Voters

President Donald Trump holds a chart as he talks with reporters after receiving a briefing on Hurricane Dorian

Evan Vucci / AP

Commerce Department Called Out Over Hurricane Dorian Forecast

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra

Rich Pedroncelli / AP

California Suing Trump Administration Over New Student Visa Policy

Defense Secretary Mark Esper testifies during a House Armed Services Committee hearing

Michael Reynolds / Pool / AP

Esper Says He Was Briefed On Alleged Russian Payments In February

John Minchillo / AP

Michael Cohen Back In Prison After Refusing Furlough Terms

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

Congress Reacts To Supreme Court Rulings On President's Taxes

President Donald Trump

Evan Vucci / AP

White House Calls SCOTUS Orders A Win, Despite Immunity Decision

Supreme Court building

Andrew Harnik / AP

Supreme Court Finds Much Of Oklahoma Is Native American Land

Joe Biden at podium

AP/ Matt Slocum

Biden Counters President Trump With 'Buy American' Economic Plan

President Donald Trump.

Patrick Semansky / AP

Supreme Court Rejects President Trump's Claims Of Complete Immunity

U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper, left, speaks during a briefing with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Army Gen. Ma

Susan Walsh / AP

Esper And Milley To Testify Thursday Before House Committee

Prescription Denied: Accessing The Abortion Pill graphic

Andrew Lawler / Newsy

Prescription Denied: Accessing The Abortion Pill

Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman

Andrew Harnik / AP

Key Impeachment Witness Alexander Vindman Retires From Army

Man walks with mask in Shiprock, New Mexico

Native American Tribes Cite Infrastructure Concerns Amid COVID-19

Members of Little Sisters of the Poor

Supreme Court Upholds Religious Exemption Rule On Contraceptives

FBI Director Christopher Wray speaking at a hearing on Capitol Hill.

Andrew Harnik / AP

FBI Director Calls China The 'Greatest Threat' To The U.S.

Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts

J. Scott Applewhite / AP

Chief Justice John Roberts Briefly Hospitalized In June

Harvard University

Charles Krupa / AP

Colleges Will Suffer If International Students Are Forced To Leave

International student Christian Jackson with friends at Drake University

Christian Jackson

International Students Will Have To Leave U.S. If Schools Move Online

The Trump Administration Considers Banning TikTok

President Donald Trump walks with Vice President Mike Pence at the 2016 RNC.

Matt Rourke / AP

RNC To Test Attendees For Coronavirus Daily

Democratic presidential candidate former Vice President Joe Biden

AP/ Matt Slocum

Biden Campaign Outraises, Outpolls President Trump

Prescription Denied: Accessing The Abortion Pill graphic

Andrew Lawler / Newsy graphics

Prescription Denied: Accessing The Abortion Pill (Trailer)

As Police Divestment Gains Support, Summer Violence Raises Tensions

Michael Wyke / AP

Kanye West Announces Bid For Presidency

President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump hold their hands over their hearts

Patrick Semansky / AP

President Trump Delivers Divisive Independence Day Speech

Kimberly Guilfoyle speaks at Phoenix campaign rally

Rick Scuteri / AP

Trump Campaign Official Kimberly Guilfoyle Tests Positive For COVID-19

A man walks past a closed business in Shaker Heights, Ohio

Tony Dejak / AP

Paycheck Protection Program Lending Extended Into August

President Donald Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

President Trump Attends Mount Rushmore Fireworks Celebration

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP

Mississippi Moves A Step Further Away From Prohibition

Laura Rauch / ASSOCIATED PRESS

Experts: President Trump's Mount Rushmore Fireworks Are Hazardous

Joe Biden and Donald Trump

Matt Rourke / Patrick Semansky / AP

Trump TV Ad Spending Is More Than Double Biden Ad Spending

U.S. Supreme Court

Supreme Court Will Likely Be An Important Issue For 2020 Voters

A supporter for the transgender community holds a trans flag.

Robin Rayne / AP

Trump Admin. To Roll Back Transgender Protections In Homeless Shelters

Mike Pence wearing a mask

Ross D. Franklin / AP

Bipartisan Calls For Masks Grow As Coronavirus Cases Surge

Ballot drop-off lane in Colorado.

David Zalubowski / AP

Colorado Primary Election Gave Trump Another Endorsement Defeat

AP / Greg Nash

Senator Says No Intel Community Officials Attended Russia Briefing

Namita Telang with her husband and daughters

Namita Telang

President Trump's Immigration Freeze Is Keeping Families Separated

American soldiers waiting for a helicopter to land in Afghanistan

Rahmat Gul / AP / File

U.S. Officials: Financial Transfers Corroborate Russian Bounties

Statue of Alexander Hamilton Stephens in the U.S. Capitol Stephens was vice president of the Confederacy.

Patrick Terpstra / Newsy

8 States Keep Confederate Statues On Display In U.S. Capitol

President Donald Trump

Evan Vucci / AP

Judge Temporarily Blocks Tell-All Book By President Trump's Niece

Joe Biden speaks in Wilmington, Del., on June 30, 2020.

Patrick Semansky/AP

Newsy/Ipsos Poll Shows Biden With 2020 Momentum

Lexington Herald-Leader / AP

Amy McGrath To Face Sen. Mitch McConnell For Kentucky Senate Seat

National Guardsmen at Washington Monument

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP

White Supremacist In National Guard Was Deployed To Floyd Protests

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds

Charlie Neibergall / AP

Iowa Governor Signs Waiting Period Abortion Law

President Donald Trump

AP/ Susan Walsh

Lawmaker Has 'Far More Questions' After Russian Bounty Briefing

Protesters rally for eviction protection during COVID-19

Experts Warn Of Looming Housing Crisis As Eviction Courts Reopen

Sue Ogrocki / ASSOCIATED PREDD

Three-Quarters Of Americans Say President Trump Should Wear A Mask

A pro-China supporter holds a Chinese national flag during a rally to celebrate the approval of a national security law.

Kin Cheung / AP

China Passes Hong Kong National Security Law

President Donald Trump

Alex Brandon / AP

Interpol Rejects Iran's Arrest Warrant For President Trump

Dmitry Astakhov / Sputnik / AP

Questions Mount After Reports Russia Paid Taliban To Kill U.S. Troops

Anti-abortion rights protester

Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Abortion Law

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before leaving The White House

AP / Alex Brandon

President Trump Retweets Video Of Supporter Shouting 'White Power'

Paratroopers conduct a rapid extraction (EXFIL) following a fly-to-advise mission in Southeastern Afghanistan.

President Trump Casts Doubt on Russia Bounty Report

The current Mississippi state flag

Rogelio V. Solis / AP

Mississippi Lawmakers Pass Legislation To Change The State Flag

File photo of Walmart distribution center

Gunman Kills 1, Injures 4 At California Walmart Distribution Center

Minors exercise at child detention center in Florida.

Wilfredo Lee / AP

Judge Rules Migrant Children Must Be Released Due To Coronavirus

Processed mail-in ballots are seen at the Bucks County Board of Elections office prior to a primary election

Matt Slocum / AP

U.S. Supreme Court Denies Request To Allow All Texans To Vote By Mail

Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton

Carolyn Kaster / AP

House Approves Washington, D.C., Statehood Bill

President Donald Trump touring section of border wall

Evan Vucci / AP

Appeals Court Rules President Trump Can't Use Military Funds For Wall

U.S. Supreme Court building

Qualified Immunity: Unjust Or Necessary?

Vice President Mike Pence and Dr. Anthony Fauci

Susan Walsh / AP

WH Coronavirus Task Force Says Local Responses To Outbreaks Are Key

Mexican guest workers at a quarry in Idaho

Northern Stone Supply

Trump's Immigration Freeze Hurting Stone Mining Businesses In Idaho

Patient gives sample for coronavirus testing

David J. Phillip / AP

Views On Coronavirus Have Become Increasingly Partisan

A shopper departs a shoe store at CambridgeSide mall, in Cambridge, MA

Steven Senne / AP

U.S. Consumer Spending Increased At Record Pace In May

A woman wearing a mask walks past in sign on the door at Pullman Foursquare Church on Thursday, June 25, 2020

The Moscow-Pullman Daily News / AP

U.S. Breaks Its Own Record For Daily COVID-19 Cases

A woman holds up a sign saying "police the police" as she confronts a police line while demonstrators protest in Washington.

Jacquelyn Martin / AP

House Passes Police Reform Legislation, Faces Senate Pushback

the setting sun shines on the Supreme Court building on Capitol Hill in Washington.

Patrick Semansky / AP

Trump Administration Urges Supreme Court To Invalidate Obamacare

President Donald Trump

Evan Vucci / AP

Court Declines To Block Publication Of Book By President Trump's Niece

Joe Biden, President Donald Trump, Vice President Mike Pence

Trump And Biden Campaigns Visit Key Battleground States

A statue of Andrew Jackson near the White House

Andrew Harnik / AP

Report: Trump Administration Asks U.S. Marshals To Protect Monuments

Missouri's only abortion clinic

Jeff Roberson / AP

Missouri's Last Abortion Clinic Issued License After Yearlong Battle

Protesters block traffic at an intersection an intersection near Capitol Square in Madison, Wisconsin.

Emily Hamer / Wisconsin State Journal / AP

Wisconsin Governor Activates National Guard Following Unrest

Butch Dill / AP

Stacey Abrams Talks Primaries, Voter Turnout And Joe Biden

U.S. Secret Service police watch as demonstrators protest the death of George Floyd

Manuel Balce Ceneta / AP

Secret Service Agents To Quarantine Following Tulsa Rally

Rep. Jerry Nadler

J. Scott Applewhite / AP

House Judiciary Chairman Now Open To Impeaching William Barr

Matt Slocum / AP

DNC Announces Scaled-Back Convention Amid Coronavirus Pandemic

D.C. police officers with shields

Maya Alleruzzo / AP

Senate Democrats Block Republican Policing Bill

President Trump speaks at TPUSA Summit

Trump, Pence Lean Into Evangelical Voter Bloc Ahead Of 2020

Whistleblower's Lawyer Is 'Disturbed' Bolton Saved Claims For His Book

Former national security adviser Michael Flynn

AP / Susan Walsh

Appeals Court Dismisses Case Against Michael Flynn

Voting stations are set up in the Kentucky Exposition Center for voters to cast their ballot in the Kentucky primary

Timothy D. Easley / AP

Early Primary Results Indicate Shakeups In Some States

Sign pointing to polling place

Ross D. Franklin/AP

Voter Outreach Groups Work To Spark 2020 Election Surge Amid Protests

First responders at door

City of Dallas

Less Police Involvement On Mental Health Calls Shows Fewer Arrests

White House trade adviser Peter Navarro

Alex Brandon / AP

Peter Navarro Walks Back Comments That China Trade Deal Is 'Over'

Members of the Coronavirus Task Force testify

AP/ Kevin Dietsch

Dr. Fauci Says COVID-19 Testing Will Ramp Up, Not Slow Down

Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton

Andrew Harnik / AP

Congress To Vote On D.C. Statehood

President Donald Trump and Joe Biden

University Of Michigan Presidential Debate Moved To Miami

A person waves an American flag in front of the White House

Carolyn Kaster/ AP

U.S. Suspends Some Worker Visas Through End Of Year

A White House physician checks someone's temperature

Evan Vucci / AP

White House No Longer Performing Temperature Checks On All Guests