(Thumbnail Image: Texas Tribune)

 

The Texas Board of Education voted to put a more conservative view to the history curriculum in schools statewide, starting a national controversy between liberals and conservatives.

 

We're taking a look at perspectives from CNN, Fox News, Mediaite and The New York Times.

CNN's Tom Foreman filed a report that focuses almost entirely on the changes conservative board members are making. He points out Texas's huge student population ensures that these changes could affect students nationwide. 

"OUT, too much talk about Thomas Jefferson and the Enlightenment, which stressed reasoning and science over faith.  IN, more recognition of the contribution of religious leaders, like Moses, to American ideals.  OUT, calling the U.S. government 'democratic,' like the party.  IN, calling it a constitutional republic.  OUT, capitalism, which some board members fear has been turned into a dirty word.  IN, free enterprise."

Fox News contributor Tucker Carlson says liberal bias has tainted history textbooks for decades and it needs to be counterbalanced. 

"So, for instance, some of the conservatives on the board have fought back against the inclusion of a very minor-league left-wing United Farm Workers activist who no one has ever heard of, they're convinced kids ought to worship at her shrine... Members of the board have said 'look, Communists did actually infiltrate the United States government after the Second World War.  McCarthy may have been a demagogue but he was right to that extent." 

The blog Medialite takes issue with Carlson's comments and also Fox News' coverage of the issue, saying they're "promoting McCarthyism." 

"It isn’t the first time a Fox News commentator has taken on the public education system’s assumed liberal bias... [Carlson] mocked the outraged reactions of the more liberal members of the board..."

The coverage by ABC focuses more on conservative members of the board, pointing out that dentist Don McLeroy has no educational background in history.

"But critics say that McLeroy and the conservative Christian block have consistently overreached...  They did successfully remove the author of the children's book 'Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?,' Bill Martin Jr., because they mistook him for another Bill Martin, who wrote a book critical of capitalism."

 

MCLEROY: "That was embarrassing.  You know, we made a mistake.  Somebody had pointed that out and they didn't do their research." 

 

HARRIS: "People are really latching onto it as an example of reckless zeal."


So are these Texas board members overstepping their bounds or are they just setting the record straight?

 

Writer: Ben Stewart

Producer: Newsy Staff

U.S. News

Texas Rewriting History Textbooks?

March 15, 2010
(2:40)
The Texas Board of Education has angered many on the left by making changes to history books that critics say represent right-leaning bias.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

University Accused of Being a 'Diploma Mill'
Audit finds Dickinson State University awarded diplomas to more than 500 students, mostly from China.
(1:53)
February 13, 2012
Europeans Take to Streets to Protest ACTA
Hundreds of thousands of Europeans took to the streets over the weekend to protest the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement.
(1:37)
February 13, 2012
Pittsburgh Steelers Cutting Ties with Hines Ward
Steeler black and yellow goes hand-in-hand with WR Hines Ward, but fans may see Ward in another uniform come next season.
(1:59)
February 13, 2012
Air Force to Provide iPads in Cockpits
The United States Air Force is following the lead of the airline industry and transitioning to paperless cockpits using tablet computers.
(1:33)
February 13, 2012
Palin Fires Up CPAC Crowd
Analyst debate how will Sarah Palin's speech impact the GOP race?
(1:46)
February 13, 2012
Media Runs Rampant With Houston Death Speculation
Just after Houston’s death news broke, the media began to speculate on the cause behind it.
(2:08)
February 12, 2012
Obama’s 2013 Budget Invests in Infrastructure, Raises Taxes
The proposed budget sends more money to transportation, cuts from military spending and relies on tax increases for high-income Americans.
(2:23)
February 12, 2012
Al Qaeda Increasingly Involved in Syria
Al Qaeda's leader urged followers to join anti-Assad rebels. U.S. officials claim the organization is already responsible for several bombings.
(1:46)
February 12, 2012
Will 'Lin-Sanity' Last Long?
Undrafted Jeremy Lin might be the next great NBA star, but can he sustain his high level of play?
(2:23)
February 12, 2012
Grammys Preview: What to Expect
From Adele's comeback performance to the always-surprising Kanye West to a last-minute Whitney Houston tribute, find out what to watch for tonight.
(1:58)
February 12, 2012
Sunday Soundbite Analysis 02/12/12
Chief of Staff Jack Lew, speaks about the fragile US economy and Obama’s controversial policy.
(3:10)
February 12, 2012
Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Whitney Houston had won 6 Grammys, 2 Emmys, 16 Billboard Music Awards and 23 Music Awards.
(2:37)
February 12, 2012
Did John Wayne Gacy Have An Accomplice?
New theories from two Chicago attorneys suggest the infamous serial killer did not work alone.
(2:17)
February 12, 2012
Madonna Stalker Recaptured After Escape
Madonna stalker Robert Dewey Hoskins escaped from a mental institution a week ago. On Friday, officers picked up Hoskins on a sidewalk in Long Beach.
(1:21)
February 12, 2012

Newsy