(Thumbnail image: Scripps-Howard)

 

Several states have readied lawsuits against the federal government. The states say they'll sue over health care reform legislation President Barack Obama signed into law. They say the federal government is overstepping its constitutional powers.

 

The CBS affiliate in Jacksonville, Florida, plays up the drama of the states’ suits.

 

"Republicans say they know where they stand on the bill, they don't want to see it become law, and that's why tonight they are banding together to fight back."

 

"...this state uprising against the federal government."

 

"The number of states jumping on the bandwagon to stop the reform is growing."

 

"...states fight for their individual rights."

 

CNN's Anderson Cooper asks tough questions of Utah's Attorney General about his ties to the health care industry.

 

COOPER: "The New York Times a little awhile ago...basically they're potentially saying that you and other attorney generals have gotten thousands of dollars in contributions from the industry.  A.) is that the case, and do you think, if so, that poses any kind of conflict."

(:39-:50)

SHURTLEFF: "In this case is not political, it's about making sure the process is followed."

COOPER: "I mean you're really not saying this is political, [SHURTLEFF: No.] there aren't a lot of Democratic attorney generals or governors signing onto this thing."

 

Likewise, Fox News' Greta Van Susteren warns Virginia's Attorney General of a potential pitfall for his state's suit.

 

"One of the problems I forsee you having is the idea of what affects the commerce clause. It's so broad. It's such a stretch, I mean the most unusual things are said to affect commerce.  I mean you could run into a judge who could say well the fact that we may have to get medical supplies from another state to take care of your ill or your sick or your injured in Virginia could really affect interstate commerce, so for that reason, you lose."

 

But the spokesman for the Reagan Political Action Committee defends the suits on Fox Business, saying that the reform legislation is too big a financial burden on states.

 

"I just got back from Texas, I was there with Gov. Perry for three days. The cost of this legislation to the state of Texas alone is $24 billion..."  

"This is why you see so many governors in so many states getting ready, and they're already doing it, suing the federal government, saying listen, you're putting this onto us and having us pay the bill.  This is going to break the back of states."

 

So what do you think? Is the federal government overstepping its bounds? Or are the states' suits motivated by more than just a stand for state's rights? 

Politics News

States Ready Lawsuits Over Health Care Reform

March 23, 2010
(2:23)
Several states are preparing to sue the federal government over health care reform legislation, citing a violation of state’s rights.
   
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Syrian Conflict at Possible 'Turning Point'
U.N. observers verify attacks for first time.
(1:39)
May 27, 2012
Top News Headlines: Afghan Officials: Airstrike Kills Family
More headlines: Four NATO troops killed in roadside bomb attacks; Syrian rebels call for Houla retaliation; rebel groups in Mali join forces.
(1:25)
May 27, 2012
PayPal Extends In-Store Purchasing
PayPal teams up with 15 new retail stores providing users with a new way to shop.
(1:48)
May 27, 2012
Knicks Hire Woodson as Head Coach
The New York Knicks removed the interim tag from now-head coach Mike Woodson. Woodson signed for what is believed to be a three-year deal as coach.
(1:46)
May 27, 2012
Internet Defense League Will Use Cat Signal to Protect Web
The group hopes to build a network that can be summoned to fight internet legislation like SOPA.
(1:48)
May 27, 2012
NASA Warns Lunar Explorers Not to Touch its Stuff
The space agency declared the area around its moon artifacts to be protected zones, asking other explorers to keep away.
(1:49)
May 27, 2012
Controversy Over Erotic Best Seller ‘50 Shades of Grey’
Libraries struggle whether to ban the book, which they say qualifies as erotica but is also one of the most checked-out books.
(2:23)
May 27, 2012
Pope's Butler Arrested Over Leaked Vatican Documents
The Pope's butler is accused of leaking confidential Vatican files to Italian media.
(1:35)
May 26, 2012
Alternate Juror Flirts with John Edwards
A female juror has been outwardly flirting with John Edwards during his trial - and Edwards has actually been responding.
(1:17)
May 26, 2012
Top News Headlines: Obama to Honor Vets on Memorial Day
More headlines: Memorial Day gas prices lower, yet still high; Experts suspicious of Iran's nuke program; Southeast braces for Beryl.
(1:25)
May 26, 2012
49ers' QB Smith Criticized for Cam Newton Comments
Smith downplayed the Panther's QB's accomplishments last year, which wasn't too popular with Newton's teammates.
(2:04)
May 26, 2012
Syrian Crisis Continues with Massacre in Houla
An attack on the Syrian town of Houla killed at least 90 people on Saturday, including around 25 children.
(1:28)
May 26, 2012
New York School Cancels Prom Condom Giveaway
A high school in New York planned to give out 500 condoms at prom to promote safe sex, but the principal changed his mind.
(1:55)
May 26, 2012
10-year-old Regains Hearing with Cochlear Implant
The implant works like a traditional hearing aid, but with higher auditory success.
(1:49)
May 26, 2012

Newsy

www2