(Thumbnail image: Creative Commons)

Attorney General Eric Holder on ABC's "This Week": "People have been given Miranda warnings. People have continued to talk. ... But I think we also want to determine whether we have necessary flexibility..."

Under a public safety exception, suspected Times Square bomber Faisal Shahzad was interrogated before law enforcement officials read him his Miranda rights.

Shahzad later waived those rights, but politicians and the media alike fiercely debated when  and even if  terror suspects should be mirandized.


Russia Today: "Could a move like that open the door for the United States to avoid proper treatment of its own citizens?"

Sen. Joe Lieberman: "Those who join such groups join our enemies, and should no longer enjoy the rights and privileges of American citizenship."

Fox News: "Should terror suspects in this country have the very same rights as we do?"

MSNBC: "When we give up our freedoms for our safety, we lose."

On MSNBC's Hardball, the Executive Director of the ACLU says there's no debating it: Miranda rights are rights.


"When you start opening up this pandora's box, whoa, we're going to have so much litigation on our hands. Congress doesn't have the power to chip away at the Fifth Amendment. That's a basic right. ... Ironically when this issue last came up in 2000, it was law enforcement officials that said they wanted Miranda. Because it made law enforcement to be effective and professionalized."

But in the National Law Journal, New York attorney Clifford Fishman says what many don't understand is that there's no constitutional right to Miranda rights.

"[Police] are under no obligation to ever give that suspect Miranda warnings. But if they do not give the warnings, the suspect's statements cannot be used as evidence of guilt at trial."

On Fox News, contributor and liberal commentator Alan Colmes says he's disappointed with hints the White House is revisiting Miranda rights for terror suspects.

"Mirandizing with the public safety exception, which has been used now in two cases in a row has worked. ... I think this would be an egregious offense to our Constitution to narrow a right that people have... (CROSSTALK) The public safety exception is already there."

But for some, that public safety exception already in place isn't enough.

For The Washington Post, syndicated columnist Charles Krauthammer offers a solution.

"The public safety exception should be enlarged to allow law enforcement to interrogate, without Mirandizing ... (and make the answers admissible) ... no Miranda rights until we know everything that public safety demands we need to know."

But we want to know what YOU think. What rights do terror suspects have? Should they differ from those of Americans accused of other crimes?

Get more political news in multiple perspectives from Newsy.com  on the Web, the iPhone, Droid and the iPad.

U.S. News

Should Terror Suspects Have Miranda Rights?

May 11, 2010
(2:36)
Obama administration officials hint the White House is reevaluating Miranda rights for terror suspects.
   
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Syrian Conflict at Possible 'Turning Point'
U.N. observers verify attacks for first time.
(1:39)
May 27, 2012
Top News Headlines: Afghan Officials: Airstrike Kills Family
More headlines: Four NATO troops killed in roadside bomb attacks; Syrian rebels call for Houla retaliation; rebel groups in Mali join forces.
(1:25)
May 27, 2012
PayPal Extends In-Store Purchasing
PayPal teams up with 15 new retail stores providing users with a new way to shop.
(1:48)
May 27, 2012
Knicks Hire Woodson as Head Coach
The New York Knicks removed the interim tag from now-head coach Mike Woodson. Woodson signed for what is believed to be a three-year deal as coach.
(1:46)
May 27, 2012
Internet Defense League Will Use Cat Signal to Protect Web
The group hopes to build a network that can be summoned to fight internet legislation like SOPA.
(1:48)
May 27, 2012
NASA Warns Lunar Explorers Not to Touch its Stuff
The space agency declared the area around its moon artifacts to be protected zones, asking other explorers to keep away.
(1:49)
May 27, 2012
Controversy Over Erotic Best Seller ‘50 Shades of Grey’
Libraries struggle whether to ban the book, which they say qualifies as erotica but is also one of the most checked-out books.
(2:23)
May 27, 2012
Pope's Butler Arrested Over Leaked Vatican Documents
The Pope's butler is accused of leaking confidential Vatican files to Italian media.
(1:35)
May 26, 2012
Alternate Juror Flirts with John Edwards
A female juror has been outwardly flirting with John Edwards during his trial - and Edwards has actually been responding.
(1:17)
May 26, 2012
Top News Headlines: Obama to Honor Vets on Memorial Day
More headlines: Memorial Day gas prices lower, yet still high; Experts suspicious of Iran's nuke program; Southeast braces for Beryl.
(1:25)
May 26, 2012
49ers' QB Smith Criticized for Cam Newton Comments
Smith downplayed the Panther's QB's accomplishments last year, which wasn't too popular with Newton's teammates.
(2:04)
May 26, 2012
Syrian Crisis Continues with Massacre in Houla
An attack on the Syrian town of Houla killed at least 90 people on Saturday, including around 25 children.
(1:28)
May 26, 2012
New York School Cancels Prom Condom Giveaway
A high school in New York planned to give out 500 condoms at prom to promote safe sex, but the principal changed his mind.
(1:55)
May 26, 2012
10-year-old Regains Hearing with Cochlear Implant
The implant works like a traditional hearing aid, but with higher auditory success.
(1:49)
May 26, 2012

Newsy

www2