(Image: x17 Online)

Nantz: "Hello friends, we have an injury report on Jason Glaspie. As you can see, his girlfriend has removed his spine, rendering him incapable of watching the game."

 

Girlfriend: "Come on, silly!"

 

Nantz: "Boy, that's hard to watch."

 

Many people had an even harder time watching this year's Super Bowl ads. Both men and women took offense at depictions of spineless, downtrodden men, over-sexed single women and grouchy, harping girlfriends. But are these commercials sexist or just silly?

We're looking at perspectives from The Today Show, The Guardian, Slate, the Washington City Paper and The Early Show.

On The Today Show, advertising guru Donny Deutsch proclaimed the 2010 Super Bowl the year of the dumb guy.

"It was men acting stupid. For some reason, this was the year, like, let’s show the American male at his stupidest, acting goofy. There was an ad for Dodge and there was an ad for Flo where it’s men whipped, talking about their miserable lives and how, you know. I don’t know what it was in our society that this year, let’s knock the guys."


But an editorial in The Guardian took a darker view of the same commercials.

"For me, the night's overarching message was clear: by choosing the brands (of television, tyres, soap and automobile) men can reassert their masculinity, escape their nagging, domineering wives and girlfriends, and be free. Buying the right kit, men, will make it easier to tolerate having to carry your girlfriend's lip balm or put up with her criticism of your slack-jawed buddies."

And a Slate "Ad Report Card" pointed out that both men and women could have cause for offense.

 

"'I will be civil to your mother, I will put the seat down,"

 

"...much of [one section] centers on how unbearable it is for men to listen to the opinions of, and on occasion respect the wishes of, women."


"Is it me, or was this year's dose of casual misogyny a little rawer and angrier than usual?"


Though men voiced much of the anger over this year's ad content, women also had concerns. On "The Sexist" blog in the Washington City Paper, writer Amanda Hess knocked GoDaddy.com for their commercial starring Danica Patrick.

 

"This ad could have been a clever subversion of standard Superbowl bodice-ripping if Patrick’s character had been allowed to point out how totally [expletive] weird this is. Instead, viewers are asked to head online to check out the even sexier action. Just a reminder that even women who excel in traditionally male fields (a girl who’s really good at driving!) are still forced into traditionally female representation (boobs!)."

But on The Early Show, USA Today reporter Laura Petrecca said that the ad failed to even capture viewer interest.

 

Anchor: "What were some of the ones that weren’t so popular, that maybe missed the mark a little bit?"

 

Petrecca: "Skechers, which is a sneaker company and GoDaddy ended up much further down on the Ad Meter list."

So, are this year's Super Bowl ads sexist? Or are they just silly?

 

Writer: Elizabeth Eberlin

Producer: Nathan Giannini

Entertainment News

Sexism and the Super Bowl

February 9, 2010
(3:03)
This year's Super Bowl ads depicted dumb, suffering men and overbearing women. Are these commercials hateful or harmless?
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Obama Announces Birth Control Compromise
President Obama's compromise on the birth control mandate gets mixed reactions.
(2:09)
February 10, 2012
Pelosi's 'Stop Colbert' Spoof Ad Goes Viral
Nancy Pelosi takes on Stephen Colbert in a YouTube campaign supporting House Democrats' roll-out of the DISCLOSE Act.
(2:20)
February 10, 2012
Obama, Romney Tap Into Mobile for Fundraising
Presidential candidates are using mobile payment device "Square" for fundraising.
(1:30)
February 10, 2012
First Loss Refuels Murray State Debate
Critics say Racers don't deserve their lofty ranking.
(1:53)
February 10, 2012
Google to Jump Into Hardware Market with Music Streamer
Google is reportedly working on a hardware system to tie into its cloud-based music offerings. Will it catch on?
(2:42)
February 10, 2012
Apple Stock Hits Another All-Time High
Apple's market valuation continues to outpace its competition, and the company is now worth more than Microsoft and Google combined.
(2:03)
February 10, 2012
Rob Gronkowski Criticized for Post-Super Bowl Partying
Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski videotaped dancing wildly in a night club the same night his team lost the Super Bowl.
(1:31)
February 10, 2012
Russians Get Creative Ahead of Elections
A chain of coffee shops in Russia is conducting its own informal poll by offering customers beverages with their favorite candidate's portrait.
(1:57)
February 10, 2012
Critics: Android's Iris Controverisal
Gizmodo breaks a report of Iris giving Bible verses in response to questions about abortion. See what else bloggers found.
(2:09)
February 10, 2012
Newsy Now: February 10 (1600 GMT)
Clashes in Greece over new austerity measures; GOP presidential hopefuls speak at CPAC; Apple market cap bigger than ever.
(1:54)
February 10, 2012
Kodak Out Of Digital Camera Business
Kodak will stop making digital cameras to maintain profitability, but some analysts are calling it the end of an era.
(2:11)
February 10, 2012
Winter Classic to be Among Biggest Ever
The NHL announced Thursday the 2013 Winter Classic will be at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor. The league expects to break fan attendance records.
(1:59)
February 10, 2012
Hackers Release Symantec's Source Code
A hacker group affiliated with Anonymous released some of the source code for Symantec's pcAnywhere program.
(2:07)
February 10, 2012
iPad 3 Rumors Have Tongues Wagging
It's February, and that means Apple's getting ready to show the world its latest project. Or is it?
(1:54)
February 10, 2012

Newsy