The public knew Steve McNair best for what he had accomplished in life: a three-time Pro-Bowler, the NFL’s co-MVP, a charitable and compassionate celebrity. But when the married, father of four was found dead with his 20-year-old girlfriend, many believe his legacy may be tainted.

Our analysis found that some in the media feel this tarnishes his playing career, while others can look past his infidelity.

One of these is sports business analyst Rick Horrow. He tells CNN he hopes people will be remember McNair for his accomplishments on the field.

“Rewrote the record books at Alcorn State, lost out to Rashaan Salaam in the Heisman trophy balloting big school versus small school. Remember he took the Titans to the 2000 Super Bowl and was 1 foot short of winning it all in Super Bowl 34. Top 25 in jersey sales, just opened up a restaurant called ‘Gridiron 9’ in Nashville. Spokesman for AirTran and on and on and on…let’s hope that is where his legacy is left.”

Fanhouse sports blogger Jay Mariotti is not quite as forgiving. He wonders how McNair will be perceived further down the line.

"Long after the football tributes fade, we'll be asking how such a respected, beloved man winds up in a living room with bullets in his head and a dead 20-year-old hookup partner nearby. Isn't this possibly the 2009 version of O.J. Simpson, backwards?"

ESPN brings us this perspective from McNair’s former coach Jeff Fisher. He says the quarterback would want to apologize for his mistakes and would ask to be remembered in a good light.

“The Steve McNair that I knew would want me to say, celebrate my life for what I did on the field. For what I did in the community, the kind of teammate that I was. That’s what the Steve McNair that I knew would want me to say.”

But FOX Sports columnist Jason Whitlock headlines with ‘Don’t be so quick to make McNair a hero’.

“I’m only willing to acknowledge four victims — McNair’s four sons… The kids, they’re victims of two horrific crimes: 1. the murder of their father; 2. their father’s apparent abandonment so that he had time to wine, dine, vacation and shack up with his jump-off.”

Boston Globe writer Bob Ryan, appearing on ESPN’s Around the Horn, says fans should separate legacy from his mistakes.

“Americans have learned to compartmentalize all this, we have to do that. We have to understand that people are flawed; be they celebrities, athletes, journalists or anything else. The fact is that people can be great players as he was, and great charity men as he was and then have a personal circumstance where he couldn’t control his emotions over a young lady...”

How will you remember Steve McNair?

Entertainment News

McNair: Superstar or Adulterer?

July 7, 2009
(3:05)
Steve McNair: Star quarterback and family man. But given the sordid facts surrounding his death, is his legacy in question?
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Google is Planning to Launch Cloud Storage System
Google has plans to launch a general cloud storage system to compete with similar offerings from Dropbox and Apple.
(2:34)
February 11, 2012
Obama Announces Birth Control Compromise
President Obama's compromise on the birth control mandate gets mixed reactions.
(2:09)
February 10, 2012
Pelosi's 'Stop Colbert' Spoof Ad Goes Viral
Nancy Pelosi takes on Stephen Colbert in a YouTube campaign supporting House Democrats' roll-out of the DISCLOSE Act.
(2:20)
February 10, 2012
Obama, Romney Tap Into Mobile for Fundraising
Presidential candidates are using mobile payment device "Square" for fundraising.
(1:30)
February 10, 2012
First Loss Refuels Murray State Debate
Critics say Racers don't deserve their lofty ranking.
(1:53)
February 10, 2012
Google to Jump Into Hardware Market with Music Streamer
Google is reportedly working on a hardware system to tie into its cloud-based music offerings. Will it catch on?
(2:42)
February 10, 2012
Apple Stock Hits Another All-Time High
Apple's market valuation continues to outpace its competition, and the company is now worth more than Microsoft and Google combined.
(2:03)
February 10, 2012
Rob Gronkowski Criticized for Post-Super Bowl Partying
Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski videotaped dancing wildly in a night club the same night his team lost the Super Bowl.
(1:31)
February 10, 2012
Russians Get Creative Ahead of Elections
A chain of coffee shops in Russia is conducting its own informal poll by offering customers beverages with their favorite candidate's portrait.
(1:57)
February 10, 2012
Critics: Android's Iris Controverisal
Gizmodo breaks a report of Iris giving Bible verses in response to questions about abortion. See what else bloggers found.
(2:09)
February 10, 2012
Newsy Now: February 10 (1600 GMT)
Clashes in Greece over new austerity measures; GOP presidential hopefuls speak at CPAC; Apple market cap bigger than ever.
(1:54)
February 10, 2012
Kodak Out Of Digital Camera Business
Kodak will stop making digital cameras to maintain profitability, but some analysts are calling it the end of an era.
(2:11)
February 10, 2012
Winter Classic to be Among Biggest Ever
The NHL announced Thursday the 2013 Winter Classic will be at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor. The league expects to break fan attendance records.
(1:59)
February 10, 2012
Hackers Release Symantec's Source Code
A hacker group affiliated with Anonymous released some of the source code for Symantec's pcAnywhere program.
(2:07)
February 10, 2012

Newsy