(Thumbnail image: Arab News)

 

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s assertion Iran is becoming a dictatorship is prompting strong international response.

 

Clinton: "We see the government of Iran, the supreme leader, the president, the parliament is being supplanted and Iran is moving toward a military dictatorship." (Al Jazeera English)



An Al Jazeera English report is critical of the secretary, suggesting the comments were motivated by U.S. desire to build more international support for sanctions against Iran.

 


"As one of the permanent members of the U.N. Security Council, China's support is critical to passing any sanctions against Tehran. But it's been reluctant to do so, because it's Iran that supplies China with most of its energy. And that's precisely why the U.S. is here, to get energy-rich Qatar and Saudi Arabia to step forward as alternative energy suppliers."

Iran's foreign minister threw Mrs. Clinton’s comments right back--suggesting the United States doesn’t fully understand the Middle East.

 

Iranian experts and news outlets also refuted Mrs. Clinton's comments. A political analyst tells Al Jazeera English,


"’If we give Hillary Clinton some more time she will be blaming Iran for global warming as well.’"

(Al Jazeera English)

And in Iran's IRIB,  

"The U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton once again baselessly accused Iran of trying to make atomic weapon [sic], while claiming that Iran's peaceful nuclear plan poses a threat against the Arab countries in the region."

(IRIB)

 

But on FOX News, former U.S. ambassador to the U.N. John Bolton says the secretary’s concerns are grounded in fact.

 

"It's been clear that power in Iran has been flowing away from the Ayatollahs, toward the Revolutionary Guard for some time. And indeed, President Ahmadinejad is an alumnus of the Revolutionary Guard, so, in effect, he helps epitomize the shift. I think what Secretary Clinton is trying to do is emphasize the role of the Revolutionary Guards because that's where the Obama administration wants to target its sanctions, but in fact, the shift in power, I think is going to make it harder to do that and I think it makes it harder on the domestic opposition in Iran and I think it makes it clearer than ever that the Revolutionary Guards who control the nuclear weapons program are not going to be negotiated out of that program.”

 

Is rhetoric against Iran legitimate or baseless? And is the United States dealing with a harmless rival or a dangerous dictatorship?

 

Writer: Elizabeth Eberlin

Producer: Newsy Staff

Politics News

Iran: Political Target or Military Dictatorship?

February 16, 2010
(2:30)
Hillary Clinton's calls for tougher sanctions on Iran have sparked worldwide opinions on the political motives of the United States.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Police Arrest First Suspect in Videotaped Gay Beating
Atlanta Police have arrested one of three suspects in a videotaped beating of a 20-year-old gay man.
(1:52)
February 13, 2012
Jump in Plastic Surgery Rates Linked to Improving Economy
Some analyst speculate the rise might be related to the improving economy. Other say it might be because of aging baby-boomers.
(1:39)
February 13, 2012
Woman Punches Son at Anger Management Class
A Louisville, Kentucky woman was charged with assault after allegedly punching her 10-year-old son in an anger management class.
(1:44)
February 13, 2012
Apple Attacks Samsung Smartphone, Files Injunction
Apple claims the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone uses technology too similar to its product and wants to stop sales of the phone in the U.S.
(1:56)
February 13, 2012
Newsy Now: February 13 (1400 GMT)
Riotous response to Greek austerity measures; Obama's 2013 budget anticipated; Pakistan's PM charged with contempt; Adele dominates Grammys.
(1:54)
February 13, 2012
University Accused of Being a 'Diploma Mill'
Audit finds Dickinson State University awarded diplomas to more than 500 students, mostly from China.
(1:53)
February 13, 2012
Europeans Take to Streets to Protest ACTA
Hundreds of thousands of Europeans took to the streets over the weekend to protest the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement.
(1:37)
February 13, 2012
Pittsburgh Steelers Cutting Ties with Hines Ward
Steeler black and yellow goes hand-in-hand with WR Hines Ward, but fans may see Ward in another uniform come next season.
(1:59)
February 13, 2012
Air Force to Provide iPads in Cockpits
The United States Air Force is following the lead of the airline industry and transitioning to paperless cockpits using tablet computers.
(1:33)
February 13, 2012
Palin Fires Up CPAC Crowd
Analyst debate how will Sarah Palin's speech impact the GOP race?
(1:46)
February 13, 2012
Media Run Rampant With Houston Death Speculation
Just after Houston’s death news broke, the media began to speculate on the cause behind it.
(2:08)
February 12, 2012
Obama’s 2013 Budget Invests in Infrastructure, Raises Taxes
The proposed budget sends more money to transportation, cuts from military spending and relies on tax increases for high-income Americans.
(2:23)
February 12, 2012
Al Qaeda Increasingly Involved in Syria
Al Qaeda's leader urged followers to join anti-Assad rebels. U.S. officials claim the organization is already responsible for several bombings.
(1:46)
February 12, 2012
Will 'Lin-Sanity' Last Long?
Undrafted Jeremy Lin might be the next great NBA star, but can he sustain his high level of play?
(2:23)
February 12, 2012

Newsy