(Image source: Vogue (France))

 

BY TRACY PFEIFFER

ANCHOR JIM FLINK

 

You're watching multisource entertainment news analysis from Newsy.

 

 

How young -- is too young?

That’s the big question surrounding a model whose recent appearance in French Vogue -- stirred up controversy.

 

The model is France’s 10-year-old Thylane Blondeau, daughter of a former amateur soccer player and a television personality. (Images: Vogue (France))

 

In their coverage, ABC reporters made no qualms about their feelings on the topic.

 

DAN HARRIS, ABC: “A lot of little girls like to play dress up, put on Mommy’s clothing and makeup, but what you are about to see, goes well beyond that. …Where are we heading, a lot of people asking that this morning.”

 

“We only showed some of the more demure shots. Some of these photos were inappropriate for putting a young child in what could very easily be called ‘sexualized positions.’”

 

The Vogue spread and other photographs featuring little Thylane have sparked outrage across the Internet.

A writer for Mommyish says -- the problem isn’t that she’s a young model -- it’s how she’s being portrayed.

 

“These photographs of Thylane are inappropriate because they not only suggest the presence of an adult viewer … but they also invite said viewer to regard her as having an adult’s sexuality.”

 

It’s complicated.

That’s what a writer for feminist website Jezebel says.

And while she doesn’t think the fashion industry’s intentions are quote- “honorable” -- she wonders if the problem also has to do with the audience.

 

“If looking at some of her many, many fashion photographs makes me feel creepy, is it because of the way the magazines and photographers have chosen to present her, or is it because of something I’m reading into the images?”

 

And in a response to that article, Movie City News agrees and says -- maybe some of the outrage -- is the result of differing social norms on either side of the pond.

 

“There are lots of European immigrants in our area, and it’s not unusual at the beach down the street to see totally naked babies and toddlers, and young girls running around only in boy trunks or bikini bottoms with no top on... I don’t have a problem with it, but I have seen other moms raise an eyebrow or talk loudly about it being ‘inappropriate.’ Really?”

 

Finally -- in its coverage, The Daily Beast looked into the legality of a 10-year-old in arguably sexual fashion spreads.

The writer notes, young models like 12-year-old Elle Fanning have also made headlines for similarly controversial pictures. The answer:

 

“Though runway models have an age minimum of 16, there are no regulations that dictate age in editorial spreads and ads."

 

Follow @Newsy_Videos on Twitter

Get more multisource video news analysis from Newsy

Transcript by Newsy

Entertainment News: Thylane Blondeau Age

How Young is Too Young for the Fashion Industry?

August 4, 2011
(2:14)
That's the big question surrounding 10-year-old Thylane Blondeau, whose recent appearance in French Vogue -- stirred up controversy.
   
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Pope's Butler Arrested Over Leaked Vatican Documents
The Pope's butler is accused of leaking confidential Vatican files to Italian media.
(1:35)
May 26, 2012
Alternate Juror Flirts with John Edwards
A female juror has been outwardly flirting with John Edwards during his trial - and Edwards has actually been responding.
(1:17)
May 26, 2012
Top News Headlines: Obama to Honor Vets on Memorial Day
More headlines: Memorial Day gas prices lower, yet still high; Experts suspicious of Iran's nuke program; Southeast braces for Beryl.
(1:25)
May 26, 2012
49ers' QB Smith Criticized for Cam Newton Comments
Smith downplayed the Panther's QB's accomplishments last year, which wasn't too popular with Newton's teammates.
(2:04)
May 26, 2012
Syrian Crisis Continues with Massacre in Houla
An attack on the Syrian town of Houla killed at least 90 people on Saturday, including around 25 children.
(1:28)
May 26, 2012
New York School Cancels Prom Condom Giveaway
A high school in New York planned to give out 500 condoms at prom to promote safe sex, but the principal changed his mind.
(1:55)
May 26, 2012
10-year-old Regains Hearing with Cochlear Implant
The implant works like a traditional hearing aid, but with higher auditory success.
(1:49)
May 26, 2012
Video from Google's Project Glass Released
Google released the first video from its Project Glass reality headset.
(1:15)
May 26, 2012
Top News Headlines: At Least 90 Dead in Syrian Attacks
More headlines: Drone strike kills suspected militants; Shooting spree in Finland; Pope's butler arrested.
(1:21)
May 26, 2012
Facebook Looking to Build Own Browser?
The social media giant may be interested in acquiring Opera Software, and grabbing their own browser in the process.
(1:29)
May 26, 2012
Nearly One Third Of Olympic Tickets Remain Unsold
Nearly a third of the London 2012 Olympic event tickets remain unsold.
(1:29)
May 26, 2012
15-Year-Old Boy Invents New Way to Detect Cancer
A 15-year-old Maryland boy won a $75,000 prize for inventing a dipstick sensor that can detect pancreatic cancer.
(1:53)
May 26, 2012
Prehistoric Flutes Date Back 40,000 Years
When scientists reanalyzed prehistoric artifacts from Germany, they discovered modern humans may have been in Europe earlier than previously thought.
(1:43)
May 26, 2012
Private Spacecraft Docks with International Space Station
SpaceX successfully docked its Dragon capsule into the International Space Station.
(2:40)
May 25, 2012

Newsy

www3
...