Wikimedia Commons / Ryddragyn

Flawed Stem Cell Study And The Problems With Peer Review

The journal Nature retracted the faulty study but says there was nothing its editors could have done to catch the flaws.

By Steven Sparkman | July 2, 2014

Well, this is disappointing. An exciting study published in January that claimed to have found a cheap and easy way to create stem cells from adult skin cells has been retracted after an investigation found the lead author guilty of plagiarism and misconduct. (Via Wikimedia Commons / Schaaf S. et al, Ryddragyn)

​The papers, published in Nature, were big news earlier this year, called a "breakthrough" and a "game changer" for offering a way to get embryonic stem cells without the embryos. (Via CNN, CBS)

"This is something that us science nerds have been watching and waiting for for more than a decade. ... If it works, I should say. If it works. This is the first step." (Via CNN)

Turns out it probably doesn't work. The papers have been out for five months but were criticized from the start for not quite adding up, and other labs have had no success trying to replicate the findings.

Back in April, the Riken Institute in Japan, where much of the research took place, released a report saying lead researcher Haruko Obokata had falsified some of the images used in her paper, recycled data from an old study that was unrelated and had taken its methods section from another paper. (Via Kyodo News, BBC)

Obokata has denied any misconduct and is being given another chance to prove her method works, though her lab will be under surveillance this time around. (Via Mainichi Shimbun)

But how did a paper with so many problems make it into one of the most prestigious journals in the world in the first place?

Well, Nature itself says in a statement on the retractions that it doesn't check every image for signs of tampering, but adds, "Editors and referees could not have detected the fatal faults in this work."

A writer for The Wall Street Journal sums up the problem, saying "Referees who examine papers typically must take the data they are given on trust."

Some writers, commenting on situations like this, have said it's more of a media problem than a peer-review problem, in that the most strenuous test of a study has always come after it's published, not before.

But, as was the case with, say, the story in 2010 about an arsenic-based life form, it's the initial publication that gets most of the media attention. (Via NASA)

That's frustrating for many scientists, and an Atlantic writer said of the arsenic life story, "This story demonstrates the large problems with the process of how science is packaged and delivered."

But then again, these stories can also be seen as a success, not necessarily for peer review, but for the scientific community as a whole.

Reviewer site Publons says, "​By no means is peer review an infallible system, and it’s the job of the scientific community to critically examine papers after publication," adding that it's encouraging that the process worked that way in this case.

As for Nature, it announced a few reforms to its review process that should hopefully cut down on the number of fraudulent studies that make it to publication in the first place.

  TRENDING IN Sci/Health NEWS
small pool of water is surrounded by dried and cracked earth that was the bottom of the Almaden Reservoir on January 28, 2014 in San Jose, California.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Justin Sullivan

Study Says Droughts In The Southwest Could Become More Frequent

A coniferous forest is shown on a mountainside.WATCHLIST
Giorgio Galeotti / CC BY 2.0

Some Trees Might Slow Climate Change Better Than Others

CocktailWATCHLIST
mariobonifacio / CC BY SA 2.0

People Who've Passed The Bar Are More Likely To Drink At The Bar

Various types of fentanyl patches are pictured.WATCHLIST
Alcibiades

Fentanyl Abuse, Overdoses On The Rise In New Hampshire

What Zika is — and what world health agencies are doing about it.WATCHLIST
Newsy / Evan Thomas

What Zika Virus Is — And Isn't

French grocery storeWATCHLIST
christine592 / CC BY ND 2.0

France Now Won't Let Its Grocery Stores Throw Away Unsold Food

LONDON - MARCH 05: A woman sits in her pod-bed dorm room at Piccadilly Backpackers on March 5, 2006 in London, England.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Scott Barbour

More Couples Aren't Sleeping Together, But Lost Love Isn't Always Why

Image of Johnny Cash and the tarantula species named after him.WATCHLIST
Joel Baldwin / Chris Hamilton et al.

There's A Tarantula Species Named After Johnny Cash

A scientist examines mosquitos.WATCHLIST
WFTX

Gulf Coast States React To Growing Cases Of Zika Virus

Medicine bottles charting the decline in new antibioticsWATCHLIST
Newsy / Andrew Lawler

Why Are There So Few New Antibiotics?

"El Jefe" is thought to be the only jaguar in the wild in the U.S.WATCHLIST
Conservation CATalyst and Center for Biological Diversity

The Only Known Wild Jaguar In The US Caught On Camera In Rare Video

Women walk their babies in the park.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Sean Gallup

Here's What People Are Saying About That New CDC Guideline

BearsWATCHLIST
Megan Coughlin / CC BY ND 2.0

New Deal Protects 85 Percent Of Canada's Massive Great Bear Rainforest

National Weather Service storm forecast.WATCHLIST
National Weather Service

Tornadoes Reported In Mississippi And Alabama

A mosquito is tested for Zika virus.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Mario Tama

First Case Of Sexually Transmitted Zika Virus Confirmed In US

Deodorant on display at a grocery store.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Justin Sullivan

Your Deodorant May Be Messing With Your Body's Microbes

Man wears a Fitbit Charge HRWATCHLIST
Fitbit

This University Now Requires New Students To Wear Fitbits

Three different species of owls sit on display at Tori-no Iru Cafe on February 23, 2014 in Tokyo, Japan.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Keith Tsuji

When Owls Bob Their Heads, They're Not Trying To Be Creepy

Joe Biden applauds President Obama at the 2016 State of the UnionWATCHLIST
Getty Images / Evan Vucci

President Obama Announces $755 Million In Cancer Funding For 2017

Health care workers in Brazil fumigate mosquitoesWATCHLIST
Getty Images / Mario Tama

The Zika Outbreak Is Officially An International Health Emergency

A photo of the surface of the moon taken by China's Change'3 Yutu rover.WATCHLIST
China National Space Administration

Until You Can Go To The Moon, These Photos Are The Next Best Thing

Bed bug infestations are becoming more common and are extremely difficult to control.WATCHLIST
U.S. Department of Agriculture / CC BY 2.0

Bedbugs Are Developing A Strong Resistance To Most Common Insecticides

An illustration of the giant, flightless bird known as Genyornis newtoni.WATCHLIST
Monash University / Peter Trusler

50,000 Years Ago, Humans Ate A 500-Pound Bird Into Extinction

Sand tiger shark with a Banded hound shark in its mouth at COEX Aquarium.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / COEX Aquarium

Shark Gives Herself More Personal Space By Eating Tank-Mate

Oswaldo Cruz Hospital staff prepare to draw blood from baby Lorrany Emily da Silva (R), who has microcephaly, on January 26, 2016 in Recife, Pernambuco state, Brazil.WATCHLIST
Getty Images/ Mario Tama

Zika Virus Prompts Brazilian Petition For More Legal Abortion Access

An artistic rendering of how the ESA's new satellite network would work.WATCHLIST
European Space Agency

Super-Fast Space Laser Satellites Could Help Save Lives On Earth

To be fair, the vulture did have tracking equipment on it that could make it look like a spy if one didn't know better.WATCHLIST
Greg Schechter / CC BY 2.0

United Nations Had To Help Israel Get Its Vulture Back From Lebanon

Babylon cuneiform tablet.WATCHLIST
Mathieu Ossendrijver (HU)

Ancient Babylonians Might Have Used Geometry To Track Jupiter

woman covers her face walking past health workers fumigating in an attempt to eradicate the mosquito which transmits the Zika virus on January 28, 2016 in Recife, Pernambuco state, Brazil.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Mario Tama

The Zika Virus Might Interrupt The 2016 Rio Olympics

Israeli mothers are seen taking part in a breast-feeding course on November 12, 2003 Moshav Udim, central Israel.WATCHLIST
Getty Images / Uriel Sinai

Breastfeeding Could Save More Than 800,000 Children's Lives A Year