“It’s nothing short of a call to overhaul the way the war is being fought. In a confidential report to the president on the Afghan war, General Stanley McChrystal says that if the coalition doesn’t beat the Taliban in the next 12 months, they never will.” (France 24)

 

In the coming weeks, U.S. President Barack Obama will have to make a decision on whether or not to follow McChystal’s recommendation. We’re following media perspectives on possible troop increases in Afghanistan from ABC News, CNN, CTV and Democracy Arsenal.

 

ABC News looks at the President’s tough choices from a political standpoint.

 

“The report underscores the greatest foreign policy challenge of the Obama presidency. The Commander in Chief isn’t sure sending more troops to Afghanistan is the answer, yet his hand picked general says the war will almost certainly be lost without them.”

 

But CNN is reporting from Kabul that the Afghan people are tired of war and would like the NATO countries to spend more on improving infrastructure in their country.

 

“When you talk to the Afghan people, the only thing surprising and shocking to them is that 8 years later we’re still discussing this. In his assessment, General Stanley McChrystal states that there needs to be better governance, there needs to be more troops on the ground. Not necessarily for warfare, but for security in a way of building infrastructure. Bringing in that civilian effort. And if you talk to the Afghan people here they’ll tell you that’s what they’ve been asking for for the past 8 years.”

 

And CTV News reports that the U.S. and other countries might be better off sending funding for security forces than troops.

 

“They’re wondering if more international troops are really the answer. They say it could only underscore or reinforce the notion to Afghans that their country is under foreign occupation. They’re saying that perhaps the better strategy might be to give the money to the Afghan security forces. Of course, the problem is training.”

 

But Michael Cohen from the blog Democracy Arsenal says General McChrystal seems to be changing the entire war strategy from defeating the Taliban to one similar to our strategy in Iraq.

 

“I understand the importance of stabilizing Afghanistan so that it won’t fall to the Taliban, but according to McChrystal that is not enough – the Afghan government must also maintain the capacity to counter transnational terrorists.”

 

What do you think? Should President Obama take the advice of General McChrystal or adapt the military strategy to help build infrastructure and support security forces already in Afghanistan?

World News

Finding the Right Path in Afghanistan

September 22, 2009
(2:26)
Discussion on whether the U.S. should send more troops to Afghanistan, as suggested by Gen. Stanley McChrystal, is heating up, as the media are weighing in on what is the best strategy to win the war.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Top Syrian General Assassinated as Violence Escalates
Media outlets say this is the first time a high-ranking military official has been killed in Syria since the crisis began.
(2:41)
February 11, 2012
Dad Shoots Daughter’s Laptop Over Facebook Post
A father shot multiple bullets into his daughter’s laptop and posted a video of it on YouTube after she wrote a “disrespectful” post on Facebook.
(2:09)
February 11, 2012
Iran Promises Announcement of 'Major' Nuclear Achievements
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad says Iran will make an important announcement. He addressed crowds Saturday celebrating the country’s 1979 revolution.
(1:38)
February 11, 2012
Candidates Vie for 'True Conservative' Mantle at CPAC
Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum touted their small government credentials at the Conservative Political Action Conference this week.
(2:33)
February 11, 2012
Blue Ivy Makes Her Debut
Beyonce and Jay-Z debut their baby girl, Blue Ivy, on Tumblr, instead of selling photos to a major magazine.
(1:46)
February 11, 2012
Brazil Police Strike Spurs Worries Over Carnival
Brazil's Carnival celebrations draw some 800,000 tourists. Analysts say the strike will have a major impact on tourism for this event.
(1:18)
February 11, 2012
Saudi Writer Arrested for Religiously Offensive Tweets
Hamza Kashgari, a Saudi journalist, posted tweets that insulted the Prophet Muhammad. He was arrested in Malaysia after he fled his country.
(2:10)
February 11, 2012
Cancer Drug Gives Hope to Alzheimer's Patients
Researchers have discovered that a cancer drug can reverse the effects of Alzheimer's disease in mice and might be applicable to humans, as well.
(1:45)
February 11, 2012
Tesla Unveils 'Model X' Prototype
Tesla's "Model X" is 100 percent electric and can cost between $67,400 to $104,400 depending on the battery pack.
(1:47)
February 11, 2012
Scientists Stimulate Memory with Electric Shocks
Scientists believe electric shock therapy for memory loss can come in handy when treating patients with Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease.
(2:04)
February 11, 2012
Newsy Now: February 11 (GMT 1400)
Violence continues in Syria; Iran promises nuclear announcement; Romney gives fiery speech to conservatives; "Linsanity" knocks off Lakers.
(1:39)
February 11, 2012
Has 'Pirate Bay' Achieved Online Immortality?
A Pirate Bay user 'Allisfine' created a torrent of the site itself, essentially allowing anyone to recreate the site if taken down.
(2:11)
February 11, 2012
Zebra Stripes: Horsefly Repellent?
A new study suggests zebras may have developed stripes to fend off blood-sucking horseflies.
(1:52)
February 11, 2012
NASA: Big Cuts to Mars Missions
NASA's planetary science program may take a big cut in 2013, grounding several future Mars missions.
(2:06)
February 11, 2012

Newsy