Debit or credit? People who opt for debit may think they’re spending only money they have, but banks now allow customers to exceed balances and charge overdraft fees. With a new law that limits credit card fees, some media sources say banks are finding other ways to make money.

We take a look at perspectives from The New York Times, The Faster Times, The Record, ABC News and MSNBC.

The New York Times reports that this year alone, banks are expected to bring in 27 billion dollars on overdraft fees. It speaks with consumer Adam Rainy who says the steep charges on debit card overdrafts are unfair.

“It seems an easy way for a bank to make several hundred dollars off one customer. And if you multiply that by hundreds of thousands of tens of thousands of customers, that’s a lot of money banks are making off of what seems to be legalized robbery.”

But a writer for The Faster Times says consumers should be responsible for managing their money.

“Instead of looking at the fees merely as a source of revenue for strapped banks (which they are), shouldn’t we also see them as a teaching tool? I remember how shocked I was the first time I paid an overdraft fee; it didn’t happen too often after that.”

But The Record disagrees, saying banks are abusing the system. It reports that U.S. Senator Charles Schumer is cracking down on banks by proposing to curb debit card overdraft fees. It quotes Senator Schumer.

“Bottom line, debit cardholders are getting scammed by their banks”

“It's time to stop them dead in their tracks. This legislation will… prevent banks from rearranging charges so that customers are placed in the worst possible position.”


A reporter on ABC News says the overdraft fees on debit cards are outrageous.

“According to Consumer reports, a typical overdraft fee on a debit card purchase translates to an annual interest rate in excess of 1 000%”

MSNBC speaks with a consumer editor who provides a solution to overdraft woes by suggesting that we go back to basics.

“How about if you just take out cash at the beginning of the week? You know what you are spending. You sort of have a more real relationship with your shopping. And you know you are not going to have any overdraft problems.”
“That’s right, cash is king.”
“Cash is king.”


Our research shows the media are both blaming banks and telling consumers to be more responsible. We want to hear what you have to say.

Business News

Debit Card Woes

September 9, 2009
(2:18)
Overdraft fees are painful for debit card users, but are they to blame or the banks are exploiting the system?
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Ellen DeGeneres Fires Back at J.C. Penney Protesters
On her talk show, DeGeneres addresses the One Million Moms protest of her as J.C.Penney's new spokesperson. Plus, see who her surprise supporter is.
(1:39)
February 9, 2012
China's Heaviest Baby Born
A 29-year-old mother in China has given birth to a big baby. Chun Chun is so big, he's broken a record.
(1:28)
February 9, 2012
Nokia to Cut 4,000 Jobs
Nokia cuts 4,000 manufacturing jobs in Europe and Mexico, relocating its smartphone assembly to Asia.
(1:32)
February 9, 2012
Victim of Atlanta Beating Comes Forward
20-year-old Brandon White has revealed himself as the victim of a three-on-one beating in Atlanta, a beating believed to be a hate crime.
(1:43)
February 9, 2012
Newsy Now: February 9 (1530 GMT)
Mortgage bailout for U.S. homeowners; Greece reaches deal ahead of EU meeting; Syrian violence continues; rumored iPad 3 image.
(1:51)
February 9, 2012
Tensions Rise Over the Falklands
Argentina launches a complaint to the UN Security Council over Britain's decision to send battleship to the Falkland Islands.
(2:40)
February 9, 2012
Jack in the Box Wants to Serve You a Bacon Shake
Jack in the Box has plans to offer a bacon milkshake, but some consumers aren't impressed.
(1:50)
February 9, 2012
Skydiver Plans Free Fall From Space
An Austrian skydiver wants to break the speed of sound by free falling from the edge of space.
(1:41)
February 9, 2012
Same-Sex Marriage Poster Couple Gets Divorce
In the wake of the latest Prop 8 ruling, the first same-sex couple married in Los Angeles is getting a divorce.
(1:54)
February 9, 2012
Path Quietly Copies Users' Address Books
Social networking app Path copies users' address books to its servers without their knowledge or approval, a developer has discovered.
(2:12)
February 9, 2012
Unlocked Lumia 800 Coming to U.S. for $900
Microsoft has announced it will be selling an unlocked version of Nokia's flagship Windows phone stateside, as part of a bundle deal.
(2:06)
February 9, 2012
Designer Karl Lagerfeld 'Little too Fat' Comment Backfires
The Chanel designer Karl Lagerfeld is under fire for dissing the Grammy-award winning Adele's weight.
(2:00)
February 9, 2012
Hackers Expose Emails About Bribes Within Russian Media
Hackers uncover emails showing pro-Putin groups paying bloggers to support the prime minister and attack his opponents.
(1:59)
February 9, 2012
Scientists Drill Into a Lost World
A Russian drilling team has broken through two miles of ice to reach a prehistoric lake. Will they find new forms of life?
(2:29)
February 8, 2012

Newsy