(Thumbnail Image: New York Daily News)


Questions are being raised about President Obama’s Supreme Court nominee, Elena Kagan, not about her opinions on key issues, but about what they say is a flat-out lack of opinions.

Kagan, a former dean of Harvard’s Law School, has never been a judge or held political office. Some say there just isn’t enough out there to determine what kind of justice she’d be. Politico says both parties are skeptical.

“President Barack Obama’s supporters on the left are questioning whether Kagan is liberal enough — and the shortage of past writings has given conservatives ammunition to attack Kagan’s qualifications for the high court.”

On Fox News, contributor Tucker Carlson calls for more writings to be released, and says the White House is covering up that Kagan is actually a liberal.


TUCKER CARLSON: "... there’s no evidence she’s a political moderate. That’s a talking point; it’s silly. She’s a liberal. ... It’s a lifetime appointment. You ought to know what the person stands for and the best way to find out is by looking at the written record, so I think they have a moral obligation, I hope they will have a political obligation to release these memos.”

A blogger for U.S. News & World Report agrees, saying President Obama is using Kagan’s scant record to push his own priorities.

“…the record available for examination is very thin. … President Obama says he wants the Senate to put a rubber stamp to her nomination and confirm her quickly, likely because he expects her to be a rubber stamp for his agenda...”

But a writer for Forbes says that Kagan’s record actually has liberals suspicious of ulterior motives.

“Kagan has prominent critics on the left who believe she is almost a closet conservative who would tilt the law significantly to the right.”

HLN quotes Republican Sen. Jeff Sessions, who says without writings to examine, Kagan’s other actions must be looked at.

“The top Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, Jeff Sessions, said her stand on gays in the military is a ‘significant issue.’ As Harvard Law School Dean Kagan banned military recruiters because of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, well Sessions says such actions deserve extra scrutiny because she has never served as a judge.”

And MSNBC did just that. The network combed through Kagan’s past to find her stances on many hot topics.

“She supported banning late-term abortion, she had in fact lobbied the president at the time to ban those, that she supported banning human cloning, and both of those could anger the left here. She also criticized don’t ask don’t tell, and that’s something conservatives are concerned about.”

So is Kagan a good fit for the Supreme Court, or are her critics justified?

 

Writer: Lauren Zima

Producer: Newsy Staff

Politics News

Critics: Kagan's (Lack of) Record Raises Questions

May 12, 2010
(2:34)
Supreme court nominee Elena Kagan has no judicial experience and few published papers, making both the left and right nervous about her nomination.
   
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Private Spacecraft Docks with International Space Station
SpaceX successfully docked its Dragon capsule into the International Space Station.
(2:40)
May 25, 2012
Bankia Suspends Shares; Multibillion Euro Bailout in Future?
The Spanish bank halts trading of its shares in advance of a board meeting. Bankia is expected to request a major bailout from the government.
(2:10)
May 25, 2012
Top News Headlines: Police Find Mother of Kids Left in Shed
More headlines: FBI identifies man in Miami plane incident; Hurricane Bud headed toward Mexico; Wall Street analysts look at Facebook's flop.
(1:24)
May 25, 2012
Exonerated Former Football Star Asks for Second Chance
After Brian Banks' rape conviction from 2002 was dismissed, he's asking NFL coaches for a chance to prove himself on the field.
(1:20)
May 25, 2012
Ukrainian Lawmakers Brawl Over Language Bill
A Ukrainian Parliament session erupted into a boxing match over the proposal to make Russian the official language of the eastern region.
(1:13)
May 25, 2012
Average Salary for CEO: $9.6 Million
According to an analysis from The Associated Press, the average salary for the head of a public company was $9.6 million in 2011.
(2:28)
May 25, 2012
Egyptian Election Pacing Toward Secular-Religious Showdown
Muslim Brotherhood candidate Mohamed Morsi and former air force chief Ahmed Shafiq poised to face off in second round.
(2:02)
May 25, 2012
French President Makes Surprise Visit to Afghanistan
The new French president visited Afghanistan vowing to pull all French troops from the country by later this year.
(1:42)
May 25, 2012
Microsoft Holds Top Spot in Google Piracy Report
Google released an online piracy report which shows that Microsoft holds the top spot for URL removal requests.
(1:37)
May 25, 2012
Top News Headlines: SpaceX Nears Historic Hookup
More headlines: Hollande visits Afghanistan; Bankia shares suspended; Suspected suicide bomb kills two in Turkey.
(1:29)
May 25, 2012
Iran Talks End in Stalemate
Lack of decisive resolution to nuclear negotiation prompts diplomats to postpone Baghdad talks.
(1:23)
May 25, 2012
New Orleans to be Largest City Without Daily Newspaper
The 175-year-old New Orleans Times-Picayune will cut back production, cut staff and focus on digital.
(1:59)
May 25, 2012
Mortgage Rates Hit Record Low
The average rate for a 30-year fixed loan fell to 3.78 percent. That's four straight weeks of lows.
(1:46)
May 25, 2012
Facebook Launches Camera App
Facebook Camera is now in the Apple app store, complete with the ability to swipe to see albums and tap to see enlarged photos.
(1:43)
May 25, 2012

Newsy

www1