The fate of a comatose woman in Italy is sparking fierce debate between the right-to-life and the right-to-die.

Hello, I’m Charlotte Bellis, and you’re watching Newsy.com.

We’re following perspectives from the Guardian, the BBC, Reuters, Agence France-Presse, Catholic news agency H20 News, and India’s NDTV.

The UK’s Independent brings us this photo of Eluana Englaro… she’s been in a coma since a car accident in 1992. She was 21 at the time.

Italy does NOT allow euthanasia… but an Italian high court honored the family’s request to allow Eluana’s clinic to stop force-feeding her and allow her to die naturally.

The Guardian brings us the perspective of Englaro’s father… who has fought to remove Eluana’s feeding tubes since 1999. He tells the Guardian:

"Do you understand that concept of needing to be free? Do you? Because it's what this is all about… I know what Eluana would have wanted in this situation because she's already told us." (The Guardian)

The BBC brings us the emotional reaction from protestors in Italy:

“‘Eluana, wake up, they want to kill you,’ protestors shouted as Eluana Englaro is driven out to the medical center where doctors were going to disconnect the feeding tubes that keep her alive.” (BBC)

Reuters gives us an overview of the political implications of the debate.

It reports the Vatican is urging Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi to push an emergency law through parliament banning the court’s ruling.

That’s a move Italian President Giorgio Napolitano calls unconstitutional.

Reuters summarizes:

“The case has split the mainly Catholic country and led to a constitutional crisis between Berlusconi and the head of state. It also sparked a debate about whether, by siding openly with Berlusconi, the Vatican was unduly interfering.” (Reuters)

Agence France-Presse highlights the pressure the Vatican is putting on Italy’s government.

AFP gives a specific example through Italy’s Health Minister who is also a devout catholic.

“[Health Minister Maurizio] Sacconi warned subsidized state hospitals last month of ‘unimaginable consequences’ if they were to suspend Englaro's nutrition.” (AFP)

Catholic news agency H20 News brings us the plea of an Italian bishop:

“I appeal to the conscience of all those who are clear they have a living person before them: Not to hesitate to care for, to defend it. And those who are skeptical-- to have the wisdom to refrain from such an irreparable decision.” (H2O)

Not all of Italy is in support of the Vatican’s stance against euthanasia.

India’s NDTV brings us the perspective of an Italian woman whose husband campaigned for his right-to-die:

“I believe it’s very materialistic to think that a person is still alive just because they’re digesting, swallowing, or breathing. I think its necessary for the church to look more closely at the philosophical and theological aspects of human life.” (NDTV)

Doctors estimate Eluana could live without force-feeding for as long as two weeks.

What do YOU think? Who has the right to decide? Leave a comment and share your thoughts… and be sure to check out our sources.

I’m Charlotte Bellis, for Newsy.com, where multiple perspectives help provide the real story.

World News

Comatose Woman Sparks Euthanasia Debate

February 9, 2009
Italy mourns the loss of Eluana Englaro - a comatose woman at the center of a live vs. death debate. Here's how Newsy.com looked at the perspectives.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Apple Attacks Samsung Smartphone, Files Injunction
Apple claims the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone uses technology too similar to its product and wants to stop sales of the phone in the U.S.
(1:56)
February 13, 2012
University Accused of Being a 'Diploma Mill'
Audit finds Dickinson State University awarded diplomas to more than 500 students, mostly from China.
(1:53)
February 13, 2012
Europeans Take to Streets to Protest ACTA
Hundreds of thousands of Europeans took to the streets over the weekend to protest the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement.
(1:37)
February 13, 2012
Pittsburgh Steelers Cutting Ties with Hines Ward
Steeler black and yellow goes hand-in-hand with WR Hines Ward, but fans may see Ward in another uniform come next season.
(1:59)
February 13, 2012
Air Force to Provide iPads in Cockpits
The United States Air Force is following the lead of the airline industry and transitioning to paperless cockpits using tablet computers.
(1:33)
February 13, 2012
Palin Fires Up CPAC Crowd
Analyst debate how will Sarah Palin's speech impact the GOP race?
(1:46)
February 13, 2012
Media Run Rampant With Houston Death Speculation
Just after Houston’s death news broke, the media began to speculate on the cause behind it.
(2:08)
February 12, 2012
Obama’s 2013 Budget Invests in Infrastructure, Raises Taxes
The proposed budget sends more money to transportation, cuts from military spending and relies on tax increases for high-income Americans.
(2:23)
February 12, 2012
Al Qaeda Increasingly Involved in Syria
Al Qaeda's leader urged followers to join anti-Assad rebels. U.S. officials claim the organization is already responsible for several bombings.
(1:46)
February 12, 2012
Will 'Lin-Sanity' Last Long?
Undrafted Jeremy Lin might be the next great NBA star, but can he sustain his high level of play?
(2:23)
February 12, 2012
Grammys Preview: What to Expect
From Adele's comeback performance to the always-surprising Kanye West to a last-minute Whitney Houston tribute, find out what to watch for tonight.
(1:58)
February 12, 2012
Sunday Soundbite Analysis 02/12/12
Chief of Staff Jack Lew, speaks about the fragile US economy and Obama’s controversial policy.
(3:10)
February 12, 2012
Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Whitney Houston had won 6 Grammys, 2 Emmys, 16 Billboard Music Awards and 23 Music Awards.
(2:37)
February 12, 2012
Did John Wayne Gacy Have An Accomplice?
New theories from two Chicago attorneys suggest the infamous serial killer did not work alone.
(2:17)
February 12, 2012

Newsy