(Thumbnail image from laborpains.org)

“One of the things that Sen. Baucus does, and you have endorsed, at least in concept is a fee. Slapping a fee on Cadillac insurance plans. The fee would go on the insurance company and not on the individual but as you know many of your allies; sen. rockafeller, other democrats and many union presidents who have helped you in this fight have said ‘you know what? That insurance company will pass that on to consumer.’ And they think it’s a backdoor way of potentially violating your promise during the campaign not to raise taxes.”

 

That was John King of CNN’s State of the Union questioning President Obama on Sunday. A sticking point in the health care debate is how to pay for reform. The Cadillac tax – on plans costing more than $8,000 for an individual and $21,000 for a family - could pay for a quarter of the Baucus plan and is drawing specific questions across the board.

 

We’re looking at perspectives from CBS, The Wall Street Journal, NPR, Thaindian.com, and The New York Times.

 

First let’s go to NPR who points out the President generally avoided answering the Cadillac question.

 

"But in response to questions about whether his plan would raise costs across the board the president told CBS: 'Health care inflation went up 5.5% this past year when inflation was actually negative.'

 

ABC: 'Health care premiums went up five and a half percent.” CNN: “Well, last year your premiums went up 5.5%, five and a half percent.'

 

And NBC: 'Five and a half increase in their premiums, even though inflation was negative on everything else.'”

 

The Wall Street Journal focused on the tax’s possible effects on organized labor – one of the president’s most strident supporters – because they tend to have lower salaries but “generous benefits.”


"We don't have Cadillac salaries," said Robert Corner, a 63-year-old who works for Nebraska's department of roads in Lincoln and earns just over $50,000 a year. His parent union, estimates that its average family health plan in Nebraska will be worth $31,000 in 2013.”

 

The New York Times reports a blanket rule for all Americans does not take in to account cost of living nationwide.

 

“People who live in high-cost areas, like the Northeast or California, would also have a greater risk that their insurance plans would set off the excise tax — not because the coverage is particularly generous, but because the price of their policies reflects the higher medical costs where they live.”

 

Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele followed Obama on CBS’ Face the Nation, framing the whole program as a tax on the middle class.

 

“All this cutting inefficiency, I mean creating efficiency and cutting costs within various programs, I mean Washington’s been saying that for generations. I mean, that’s just not the business of government. It doesn’t do that. And I don’t think in something particularly mammoth as health care that you’re going to be able to go in and create a trillion dollars worth of savings.”

 

A blogger on Thaindian.com said that quantity or quality aspect of the Baucus proposal may still change the powerful minds of healthcare lobbyists.

 

“As they scoured the 223-page document, many of the most influential players found elements to dislike, but the prospect of gaining 30 million new customers may yet win the day for Obama, analysts suggested.”

Politics News

'Cadillac Tax' Raises Some Eyebrows

September 23, 2009
(3:21)
The Cadillac Tax has emerged as a way to help pay for Baucus's health care proposal, but it is drawing criticism from all sides.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Top Syrian General Assassinated as Violence Escalates
Media outlets say this is the first time a high-ranking military official has been killed in Syria since the crisis began.
(2:41)
February 11, 2012
Dad Shoots Daughter’s Laptop Over Facebook Post
A father shot multiple bullets into his daughter’s laptop and posted a video of it on YouTube after she wrote a “disrespectful” post on Facebook.
(2:09)
February 11, 2012
Iran Promises Announcement of 'Major' Nuclear Achievements
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad says Iran will make an important announcement. He addressed crowds Saturday celebrating the country’s 1979 revolution.
(1:38)
February 11, 2012
Candidates Vie for 'True Conservative' Mantle at CPAC
Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum touted their small government credentials at the Conservative Political Action Conference this week.
(2:33)
February 11, 2012
Blue Ivy Makes Her Debut
Beyonce and Jay-Z debut their baby girl, Blue Ivy, on Tumblr, instead of selling photos to a major magazine.
(1:46)
February 11, 2012
Brazil Police Strike Spurs Worries Over Carnival
Brazil's Carnival celebrations draw some 800,000 tourists. Analysts say the strike will have a major impact on tourism for this event.
(1:18)
February 11, 2012
Saudi Writer Arrested for Religiously Offensive Tweets
Hamza Kashgari, a Saudi journalist, posted tweets that insulted the Prophet Muhammad. He was arrested in Malaysia after he fled his country.
(2:10)
February 11, 2012
Cancer Drug Gives Hope to Alzheimer's Patients
Researchers have discovered that a cancer drug can reverse the effects of Alzheimer's disease in mice and might be applicable to humans, as well.
(1:45)
February 11, 2012
Tesla Unveils 'Model X' Prototype
Tesla's "Model X" is 100 percent electric and can cost between $67,400 to $104,400 depending on the battery pack.
(1:47)
February 11, 2012
Scientists Stimulate Memory with Electric Shocks
Scientists believe electric shock therapy for memory loss can come in handy when treating patients with Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease.
(2:04)
February 11, 2012
Newsy Now: February 11 (GMT 1400)
Violence continues in Syria; Iran promises nuclear announcement; Romney gives fiery speech to conservatives; "Linsanity" knocks off Lakers.
(1:39)
February 11, 2012
Has 'Pirate Bay' Achieved Online Immortality?
A Pirate Bay user 'Allisfine' created a torrent of the site itself, essentially allowing anyone to recreate the site if taken down.
(2:11)
February 11, 2012
Zebra Stripes: Horsefly Repellent?
A new study suggests zebras may have developed stripes to fend off blood-sucking horseflies.
(1:52)
February 11, 2012
NASA: Big Cuts to Mars Missions
NASA's planetary science program may take a big cut in 2013, grounding several future Mars missions.
(2:06)
February 11, 2012

Newsy