The burning question lingering in the NBA is how old is old enough? As of right now the NBA age limit requires players to be 19 and one year removed from high school.  But this age limit has raised questions and sparked controversy and commissioner David Stern is trying to raise the age limit to 20.

Hello I’m Erica Nochlin.  Newsy.com is tracking perspectives on reaction to the NBA’s age limit.

First we have a perspective from Interbasket.net that describes why there is an age limit.

"The minimum-age rule effectively put an end to all the high school phenoms skipping college and entering their names into the NBA draft.  The rule was also created in hopes that high school players would spend a year (or three) in college developing their skills, talent, maturity so that they would be better-prepared for the NBA, on and off the court."

But many notable NBA players were successful jumping straight from high school to the pros.  They include:
LeBron James, Kevin Garnett, Kobe Bryant, Dwight Howard, Amare Stoudamire and the list continues.

So why do they have to wait now?  Former coach and well-known broadcaster Dick Vitale disagrees with the age limit.


“Would you deny someone like Tiger Woods, Alex Rodriguez or Venus and Serena Williams the chance to turn pro and earn a living before turning 20? No, because we live in America, and the right to do what you desire is one of the great gifts we have in this country. It's all about freedom, man!”

And basketball legend Oscar Robertson who also disagrees with the age limit shared his perspective on ESPN’s Radio show Mike and Mike.


“What about the kids going to fight in Iraq and Afghanistan? Do they go at 18? They do.  Then that answers that question.  I think what you see now is some talks between the NBA and the NCAA about keeping stars in college so colleges can make some revenue off of them.”

The current system requires players play at least one year in college before turning pro. This “one year removed” stipulation in the rule has caused problems in the recruiting process. CBS says this results in greedy universities paying their “one year” players: example OJ Mayo.

“One argument is that forcing elite prospects into college for a one-year pit stop invites problems regarding agents prematurely investing in players. And he's correct. It's a recipe for probation”

Do you agree with NBA commissioner that players need to wait before turning pro?  What is to stop these kids from going to Europe to play professionally?  What would your age limit be?

U.S. News

Age and the NBA

May 22, 2009
(2:40)
Is an age requirement of 19 to play in the NBA fair or should they just let the kids play? Newsy.com looks at a variety of perspectives.
   
YOU NEED FLASH TO VIEW THIS VIDEO
TRANSCRIPT

To leave a comment, please log in with Facebook Connect or your Newsy account. Register here to create one.
MOST RECENT|MOST POPULAR|MOST COMMENTED|HIGHEST RATED

Ellen DeGeneres Fires Back at J.C. Penney Protesters
On her talk show, DeGeneres addresses the One Million Moms protest of her as J.C.Penney's new spokesperson. Plus, see who her surprise supporter is.
(1:39)
February 9, 2012
China's Heaviest Baby Born
A 29-year-old mother in China has given birth to a big baby. Chun Chun is so big, he's broken a record.
(1:28)
February 9, 2012
Nokia to Cut 4,000 Jobs
Nokia cuts 4,000 manufacturing jobs in Europe and Mexico, relocating its smartphone assembly to Asia.
(1:32)
February 9, 2012
Victim of Atlanta Beating Comes Forward
20-year-old Brandon White has revealed himself as the victim of a three-on-one beating in Atlanta, a beating believed to be a hate crime.
(1:43)
February 9, 2012
Newsy Now: February 9 (1530 GMT)
Mortgage bailout for U.S. homeowners; Greece reaches deal ahead of EU meeting; Syrian violence continues; rumored iPad 3 image.
(1:51)
February 9, 2012
Tensions Rise Over the Falklands
Argentina launches a complaint to the UN Security Council over Britain's decision to send battleship to the Falkland Islands.
(2:40)
February 9, 2012
Jack in the Box Wants to Serve You a Bacon Shake
Jack in the Box has plans to offer a bacon milkshake, but some consumers aren't impressed.
(1:50)
February 9, 2012
Skydiver Plans Free Fall From Space
An Austrian skydiver wants to break the speed of sound by free falling from the edge of space.
(1:41)
February 9, 2012
Same-Sex Marriage Poster Couple Gets Divorce
In the wake of the latest Prop 8 ruling, the first same-sex couple married in Los Angeles is getting a divorce.
(1:54)
February 9, 2012
Path Quietly Copies Users' Address Books
Social networking app Path copies users' address books to its servers without their knowledge or approval, a developer has discovered.
(2:12)
February 9, 2012
Unlocked Lumia 800 Coming to U.S. for $900
Microsoft has announced it will be selling an unlocked version of Nokia's flagship Windows phone stateside, as part of a bundle deal.
(2:06)
February 9, 2012
Designer Karl Lagerfeld 'Little too Fat' Comment Backfires
The Chanel designer Karl Lagerfeld is under fire for dissing the Grammy-award winning Adele's weight.
(2:00)
February 9, 2012
Hackers Expose Emails About Bribes Within Russian Media
Hackers uncover emails showing pro-Putin groups paying bloggers to support the prime minister and attack his opponents.
(1:59)
February 9, 2012
Scientists Drill Into a Lost World
A Russian drilling team has broken through two miles of ice to reach a prehistoric lake. Will they find new forms of life?
(2:29)
February 8, 2012

Newsy